
A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Hi,
The following position was reach during the recent African championship, in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang:
White to move
Is your program able to find here the white drawing move ?
Note : I am not quite happy with Damy because it needs 28 minutes (!?) to find this drawing move. What are the performance of your program?
The following position was reach during the recent African championship, in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang:
White to move
Is your program able to find here the white drawing move ?
Note : I am not quite happy with Damy because it needs 28 minutes (!?) to find this drawing move. What are the performance of your program?
Gérard
-
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 17:16
- Real name: Krzysztof Grzelak
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
The program Kingsrow rated position after 14 minutes as a movement 22-18 a draw at depth 30. The test was performed in the following equipment:
processor - I7 2670QM
ram - 16 GB DDR3 1333
hard drive - Samsung ssd 1 TB
hashtable size - 512 mb
cache size - 14500 mb
max pieces - 8
processor - I7 2670QM
ram - 16 GB DDR3 1333
hard drive - Samsung ssd 1 TB
hashtable size - 512 mb
cache size - 14500 mb
max pieces - 8
-
- Posts: 862
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 14:53
- Real name: Ed Gilbert
- Location: Morristown, NJ USA
- Contact:
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
I get a much faster result than Krzysztof's. Perhaps you were using a small hashtable setting?
Draw 22-18 in 25 seconds at depth 31.
CPU ES-2630 v3 @ 2.4 GHz
hashtable: 512mb
search threads: 5
egdb cache: 16gb
Draw 22-18 in 25 seconds at depth 31.
CPU ES-2630 v3 @ 2.4 GHz
hashtable: 512mb
search threads: 5
egdb cache: 16gb
-
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 17:16
- Real name: Krzysztof Grzelak
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
In fact, I had set the option Search threads on 1. I forgot to switch on 8. Ed too good computer you have.
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Thank you for your answers. I try to build a new search algorithm but I have still a lot of work to do!
Gérard
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Gerard, at least welcome back in this forum.
Would like to learn a lot about your new Damy developments and your new insights...
Bert
Would like to learn a lot about your new Damy developments and your new insights...
Bert
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
HI,BertTuyt wrote:Gerard, at least welcome back in this forum.
Would like to learn a lot about your new Damy developments and your new insights...
Bert
A lot of work has still to be done but I am already happy with the first results. My new algorithm is based on several new ideas:
1) Instead of developping a tree I develop a network in order to detect easily the loops
2) With the availability of large memory, instead of keeping results in a hashtable, I keep in memory millions of positions link together in a large network
3) Instead of managing bound values associated to alpha-beta procedure I manage only a real evaluation of each position which is improved each time the position is visited by the exploration algorithm
BTW I do not see on the forum how to build a diagram? can somebody help me?
Gérard
-
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: Thu Jun 20, 2013 17:16
- Real name: Krzysztof Grzelak
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
To present the diagram on the forum, you must enter the site http://fmjd.org/dias2/index.php. Set the appropriate position click "send " and "Save On Server" and later paste the link to the diagram on the forum. Give an example.

Only I'm not sure about that matter.
Krzysztof

Only I'm not sure about that matter.
Krzysztof
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Thank you Krzysztof for your help!

White to play
With the relevant 8 pieces in memory it takes less than 2 minutes to Damy to prove the loss. I am wondering if it is a good start for my new algorithm?
Any reaction to help me?

White to play
With the relevant 8 pieces in memory it takes less than 2 minutes to Damy to prove the loss. I am wondering if it is a good start for my new algorithm?
Any reaction to help me?
Gérard
-
- Posts: 862
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 14:53
- Real name: Ed Gilbert
- Location: Morristown, NJ USA
- Contact:
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Hi Gerard,
Kingsrow cannot see a db win after 1/2 hour of search, only a nearly 2-man advantage for black. What is your PV?
-- Ed
Kingsrow cannot see a db win after 1/2 hour of search, only a nearly 2-man advantage for black. What is your PV?
-- Ed
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Hi Ed,

White to play
My PV is the following
1.35-30 24x35 2.28-22 23-28 3.32x12 21x41 4.12-7 19-23 5.7-1 41-46 6.1x29 46-28 7.38-32 28x6 8.29-1 6-17 9.32-27 17-3 10.1-7 3-21
11.27-22 26-31 12.7-23 21-8 13.23-7 13-19 14.33-28 31-36 15.7-23 8-3 16.23x5 3-12 17.22-17 12x26 18.34-29 26-48 19.39-33 25-30 20.29-23 48-42 and the db is reached

White to play
My PV is the following
1.35-30 24x35 2.28-22 23-28 3.32x12 21x41 4.12-7 19-23 5.7-1 41-46 6.1x29 46-28 7.38-32 28x6 8.29-1 6-17 9.32-27 17-3 10.1-7 3-21
11.27-22 26-31 12.7-23 21-8 13.23-7 13-19 14.33-28 31-36 15.7-23 8-3 16.23x5 3-12 17.22-17 12x26 18.34-29 26-48 19.39-33 25-30 20.29-23 48-42 and the db is reached
Gérard
-
- Posts: 862
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 14:53
- Real name: Ed Gilbert
- Location: Morristown, NJ USA
- Contact:
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Gerard, that is a very good result. I would say your new program is working very well.
The position looks somewhat like the Woldouby position, W:W25,27,28,30,32,33,34,35,37,38:B12,13,14,16,18,19,21,23,24,26. Does Damy now see a draw there?
-- Ed
The position looks somewhat like the Woldouby position, W:W25,27,28,30,32,33,34,35,37,38:B12,13,14,16,18,19,21,23,24,26. Does Damy now see a draw there?
-- Ed
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Yes Ed, the Woldouby position is quite easy for Damy. With the relevant bdd already in the cache, Damy needs 2 seconds to prove the draw.Ed Gilbert wrote:Gerard, that is a very good result. I would say your new program is working very well.
The position looks somewhat like the Woldouby position, W:W25,27,28,30,32,33,34,35,37,38:B12,13,14,16,18,19,21,23,24,26. Does Damy now see a draw there?
-- Ed
Gérard
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Gerard, thats amazing...
Do you use a 7P or 8P DB?
Bert
Do you use a 7P or 8P DB?
Bert
Re: A difficult endgame in the game Coulibali - Ndjofang
Hi Bert,BertTuyt wrote:Gerard, thats amazing...
Do you use a 7P or 8P DB?
Bert
I use of course the 8p db. Anyway with my previous algorithm I was not able to resolve completly the positions given above so it was a very good news for me to see such inexpected results.
Gérard