For the first time the Personal World Championship Endgame composition (PWCE) is conducted under the responsibility of the FMJD. The CPI of the FMJD has organized the competition and three jury members scored the participating compositions, presented to them without the names of the participants by the contact Mr. Ceron of France.
The competition is divided in three categories and the rules to be applied are the RIE (Rules International Endgames) prepared by the CPI.
The first phase of the competition is that the jury members have a look at the end games to see if the participating end games are in accordance with the conditions of the competition and the RIE. If not these end games are excluded from further participation. The remaining end games are scored by the individual jury members and from the scorers of the three jury members together the result is calculated.
This result is first presented in such a way that only the ranking per category is presented, not yet the names of the participants or the scores of the jury members. This is called the preliminary result.
With the publication of the preliminary result the participants get the opportunity to object against elimination or to make other relevant remarks. These remarks are not sent to the owners of the Internet sites, but to the contact Mr. Ceron.
When the remarks have been studied and dealt with, the final result is published including the names of the participants and the scores of the jury members.
Jaap Bus
CPI President
<a href="http://fmjd.org/downloads/PWCE_prelimin ... .doc">PWCE preliminary results.doc</a> <br>
<a href="http://fmjd.org/downloads/Concours_PWCE ... _categorie A_resultat_provisoire.doc</a><br>
<a href="http://fmjd.org/downloads/Concours_PWCE ... _categorie B_resultat_provisoire.doc</a><br>
<a href="http://fmjd.org/downloads/Concours_PWCE ... _categorie C_resultat_provisoire.doc</a>
Preliminary results WC End Game composition
-
Shkludov
http://plus.gambler.ru/phpbb/viewtopic. ... rt=200&212
ÎÒÊÐÛÒÛÅ ÎÁÐÀÙÅÍÈß
Ãëóáîêîóâàæàåìûé Ïðåçèäåíò FMJD,
óâàæàåìûå ãîñïîäà, äîðîãèå êîëëåãè,
I. ÇÀßÂËÅÍÈÅ ÑÓÄÅÉ PERSONAL WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP END – GAME (PWCE) R.MACKEVICIUS è P.SHKLUDOV
Íà ñàéòå FMJD ïðåçèäåíò Committee of the Problemism International (CPI) FMJD Mr.J.Bus îáúÿâèë ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå ðåçóëüòàòû Personal World Championship End – games (PWCE).
Ìû, 2 ñóäåé PWCE (âñåãî â PWCE ñóäèëè 3 ñóäüè), ïðîòåñòóåì ïðîòèâ ôàëüñèôèêàöèè ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE:
1.  PWCE åñòü íåñêîëüêî ïîçèöèè, â êîòîðûõ îäíè ñóäüè ïîçèöèè äàþò î÷êè, äðóãèå ñóäüè äàþò 0 î÷êîâ. Mr.J.Bus ÷åðåç êîîðäèíàòîðà PWCE Mr.J.Ceron íà÷àë äàâëåíèå íà ñóäåé, ÷òîáû ìû ýòè ýòþäàì èçìåíèëè ñâîè íóëåâûå îöåíêè íà ïîëîæèòåëüíûå îöåíêè.  èòîãå:
1.1. Ñóäüÿ R.Mackevicius íå èçìåíèë ñâîèõ íóëåâûõ îöåíîê.
1.2. Ñóäüÿ P.Shkludov óêàçàë íà ïóíêòû Regles Internationales (RI) CPI FMJD, ñîãëàñíî êîòîðûõ êîìïîçèöèè äîëæíû áûëè ïîëó÷èòü íóëåâûå îöåíêè. Íî, âèäÿ, ÷òî ýòà èíôîðìàöèÿ Mr.J.Bus íå èíòåðåñóåò, äàë ýòèì ïîçèöèÿì ìèíèìàëüíûå îöåíêè (01 – 02 î÷êà â 100 î÷êîâîé øêàëå).
2. Ïî îáúÿâëåííûì ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûì ðåçóëüòàòàì PWCE ìû âèäèì, ÷òî Mr.J.Bus, áåç íàøåãî ñîãëàñèÿ, èçìåíèë íàøè îöåíêè è ýòèì ïîçèöèÿì äàë çíà÷èòåëüíî áîëåå âûñîêèå îöåíêè, ïîìåíÿâ íàøè íóëåâûå è ìèíèìàëüíûå îöåíêè.  ñâÿçè ñ ýòèì ìû ñïðàøèâàåì:
Ãäå â RI CPI FMJD èëè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE íàïèñàíî, ÷òî ïðåçèäåíò CPI FMJD, CPI FMJD, êîîðäèíàòîð PWCE èëè äðóãîå ëèöî ìîæåò ìåíÿòü îöåíêè ñóäåé PWCE?
3.  èòîãå 2 ïîçèöèè PWCE, êîòîðûì ïîëîæèòåëüíûå, ñðàâíèòåëüíî âûñîêèå îöåíêè äàë òîëüêî ñóäüÿ PWCE Mr.G.L.de Bruijn, à ìû äàëè 0 è 01, 02 î÷êà, ïîñëå èçìåíåíèÿ áåç íàøåãî ñîãëàñèÿ íàøèõ îöåíîê íà îöåíêè â óðîâíå 30 – 50 î÷êîâ, â ñâîèõ êàòåãîðèÿõ çàíÿëè î÷åíü âûñîêèå 6 è 10 ìåñòà. Ýòî ìîæåò èìåòü ðåøàþùåå âëèÿíèå íà ðàñïðåäåëåíèå èòîãîâûõ ìåñò íà PWCE.
Ìû íå èìååì ïðàâà îáúÿâèòü ïîäðîáíîñòè (íîìåðà êîíêðåòíûõ ïîçèöèè, áîëåå êîíêðåòíûå îöåíêè è ò.ä.), òàê êàê ýòî áóäåò íàðóøåíèåì RI FMJD CPI â îòíîøåíèå ïðîâåäåíèÿ ñîðåâíîâàíèé. Äî îáúÿâëåíèÿ èòîãîâûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE íåëüçÿ ðàçãëàøàòü ïîäîáíóþ èíôîðìàöèþ. Íî ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ îêîí÷àòåëüíûõ èòîãîâ óæå áóäåò ïîçäíî.
Rimas Mackevicius ñóäüÿ PWCE
Piotr Shkludov ñóäüÿ PWCE
03 – 06 – 2006
II. ÇÀßÂËÅÍÈÅ ×ËÅÍÀ CPI FMJD A.KACIUSKA
1. Âîïðîñ èçìåíåíèÿ íóëåâûõ îöåíîê íåêîòîðûõ ñóäåé íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE îáñóæäàëñÿ â CPI FMJD. Íèêàêîãî ïðîòîêîëà CPI FMJD, íèêàêîãî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ ïî ýòèì âîïðîñàì íå áûëî è íåò. ß âñåãäà áûë ïðîòèâ èçìåíåíèÿ îöåíîê ñóäåé áåç èõ ñîãëàñèÿ. Ñîçíàþ, ÷òî òàêèå ïðåöåäåíòû áûëè è åñòü â äðóãèõ âèäàõ ñïîðòà, íî ïîðÿäîê ïîäîáíûõ àïåëëÿöèè, èçìåíåíèè äîëæåí áûòü îïðåäåëåí â ñîîòâåòñòâóþùèõ äîêóìåíòàõ äî íà÷àëà ñîðåâíîâàíèè.
2. 14 – 05 - 2006 ÿ íàïðàâèë ñëåäóþùåå ïèñüìî:
Original Message -----
From: Algimantas
To: jaapbus@t-online.de ; hiltex@wxs.nl ; vpmatus@rambler.ru ; Intlegal@Rim2000.ru
Cc: Jacques Ceron ; Rimas ; shkludov@mail.ru ; Gerrit de Bruijn
Sent: Sunday, May 14, 2006 11:52 PM
Subject: PWCE
Dear Mr. J.Bus, dear Mr. J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD has not made of any decision concerning Mr. J.Ceron (PWCE): there was no voting, there is no report of the decision on this question, opinions of members CPI on this question dispatch. The decision was accepted by one person - Mr. J.Bus.
2. From judges PWCE Mr. P.Shkludov, Mr. R.Mackevicius I have learned, that Mr. J.Ceron, being based on decision Mr. J.Bus, without the coordination with judges, have changed their estimations to some positions PWCE (as estimations I are changed do not know and I do not wish to know). The specified judges protest. Estimations are changed WITHOUT the COORDINATION With JUDGES And WITHOUT DECISION CPI FMJD. It is not stipulated neither in RI CPI FMJD, nor in Rules PWCE. It is inadmissible and I make the protest.
3. I consider, that the announcement of preliminary results without discussion of the given fact and the given situation in CPI and, probably, in CD FMJD or GA FMJD, impossible.
4. I am compelled to send this letter and to the first âèöå to president FMJD, me very dear Mr. P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.J.Bus, dear Mr.J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD íå ïðèíÿëà íèêàêîãî ðåøåíèÿ ïî âîïðîñàì Mr.J.Ceron (PWCE): íå áûëî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ, íåò ïðîòîêîëà ðåøåíèÿ ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó, ìíåíèÿ ÷ëåíîâ CPI ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó ðàçîøëèñü. Ðåøåíèå ïðèíÿë îäèí ÷åëîâåê - Mr.J.Bus.
2. Îò ñóäåé PWCE Mr.P.Shkludov, Mr.R.Mackevicius ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî Mr.J.Ceron, îñíîâûâàÿñü íà ðåøåíèå Mr.J.Bus, áåç ñîãëàñîâàíèÿ ñ ñóäüÿìè, ïîìåíÿë èõ îöåíêè íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE (êàê èçìåíåíû îöåíêè ÿ íå çíàþ è íå õî÷ó çíàòü). Óêàçàííûå ñóäüè ïðîòåñòóþò. Îöåíêè èçìåíåíû ÁÅÇ ÑÎÃËÀÑÎÂÀÍÈß Ñ ÑÓÄÜßÌÈ È ÁÅÇ ÐÅØÅÍÈß CPI FMJD. Ýòî íå ïðåäóñìîòðåíî íè â RI CPI FMJD, íè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE. Ýòî íåäîïóñòèìî è ÿ âûðàæàþ ñâîé ïðîòåñò.
3. ß ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî îáúÿâëåíèå ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ áåç îáñóæäåíèÿ äàííîãî ôàêòà è äàííîé ñèòóàöèè â CPI è, âîçìîæíî, â CD FMJD èëè GA FMJD, íåâîçìîæíîå.
4. Ýòî ïèñüìî ÿ âûíóæäåí îòïðàâèòü è ïåðâîìó âèöå ïðåçèäåíòó FMJD, ìíîþ î÷åíü óâàæàåìîìó Mr.P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
3. Ïîñëå 14 – 05 – 2006 ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî J.Bus ÷àñòè÷íî ïîääåðæàë äðóãîé ÷ëåí CPI Mr.V.Matus (íî, ïîâòîðÿþ, íèêàêîãî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ è íèêàêîãî ïðîòîêîëà CPI FMJD íå áûëî è íåò) è ÷òî Mr.P.Shkludov âûïîëíèë òðåáîâàíèå Mr.J.Bus - âûñòàâèë îöåíêè ñïîðíûì ïîçèöèÿì. Ïîñëå ýòîãî ÿ ðåøèë áîëüøå íå ïðîòåñòîâàòü (òàê êàê ñóäåéñòâî è îáúÿâëåíèå ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE î÷åíü çàäåðæàëîñü), íî çàÿâèë, ÷òî ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE, ÿ âñå òàêè îôèöèàëüíî çàäàì âîïðîñ íà îñíîâå êàêèõ äîêóìåíòîâ áûëè èçìåíû íóëåâûå îöåíêè Mr.R.Mackevicius.
4. Ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ ÿ îò ñóäåé PWCE óçíàë, ÷òî áåç èõ ñîãëàñèÿ èçìåíåíû íå òîëüêî îöåíêè Mr.R.Mackevicius, íî ñóùåñòâåííî çàâûøåíû è îöåíêè Mr.P.Shkludov! Èçìåíåíèå îöåíîê Mr.P.Shkludov â CPI âîîáùå íå îáñóæäàëîñü. ß ïîääåðæèâàþ âûâîä Mr.R.Mackevicius è Mr.P.Shkludov, ÷òî ýòî – ôàëüñèôèêàöèÿ èòîãîâ PWCE.
5. Ïî ïðîñüáå Mr.R.Mackevicius è Mr.P.Shkludov ÿ ðàñïîñòðàíÿþ è èõ çàÿâëåíèå.
Algimantas Kaciuska ÷ëåí CPI FMJD
05 – 06 – 2006
-------------------------------------------------
(êîìïüþòåðíûé ïåðåâîä íà àíãëèéñêèé)
-------------------------------------------------
THE OPEN REFERENCES
Dear President FMJD,
Dear sirs, dear colleagues,
I. The APPLICATION of JUDGES PERSONAL WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP END – GAME (PWCE) R.MACKEVICIUS and P.SHKLUDOV
On site FMJD president Committee of the Problemism International (CPI) FMJD Mr. J.Bus has declared preliminary results Personal World Championship End – games (PWCE).
We, 2 judges PWCE (all in PWCE 3 judges judged), protest against falsification of results PWCE:
1. In PWCE there is some position in which one judges of a position give glasses, other judges give 0 glasses. Mr. J.Bus through coordinator PWCE Mr. J.Ceron has begun pressure upon judges that we these to etudes have changed the zero estimations to positive estimations. As a result:
1.1. Judge R.Mackevicius has not changed the zero estimations.
1.2. Judge P.Shkludov has specified items Regles Internationales (RI) CPI FMJD according to which compositions should were to receive zero estimations. But, seeing, that this information Mr. J.Bus does not interest, has given these positions the minimal estimations (01 – 02 spots in 100 a scale).
2. By declared preliminary results PWCE we see, that Mr. J.Bus, without our consent, has changed our estimations and to these positions has given much higher estimations, having changed our zero and minimal estimations. In this connection we ask:
Where in RI CPI FMJD or in Rules PWCE it is written, what president CPI FMJD, CPI FMJD, coordinator PWCE or other person can change estimations of judges PWCE?
3. As a result of 2 positions PWCE to which positive, rather high estimations were given only by judge PWCE Mr. G.L.de Bruijn, and we have given 0 and 01, 02 spots, after change without our consent of our estimations to estimations in a level 30 – 50 glasses, in the categories have borrowed very high 6 and 10 places. It can have solving influence on distribution of final places on PWCE.
We have no right to declare a detail (number concrete a position, more concrete estimations, etc.) as it will be infringement RI FMJD CPI in the attitude of carrying out of competitions. Up to the announcement of final results PWCE it is impossible to disclose the similar information. But after the announcement of adjusted totals already will be late.
Rimas Mackevicius judge PWCE
Piotr Shkludov judgePWCE
03 – 06 – 2006
II. THE APPLICATION OF MEMBER CPI FMJD A.KACIUSKA
1. The question of change of zero estimations of some judges to some positions PWCE was discussed in CPI FMJD. Any report CPI FMJD, no voting on these questions existed and is not present. I always was against change of estimations of judges without their consent. I understand, that such precedents were and there is in other kinds of sports, but an order similar to the appeal, change should be certain in corresponding documents prior to the beginning competition.
2.14 – 05 - 2006 I have sent the following letter:
Original Message -----
From: Algimantas
To: jaapbus@t-online.de ; hiltex@wxs.nl ; vpmatus@rambler.ru ; Intlegal@Rim2000.ru
Cc: Jacques Ceron ; Rimas ; shkludov@mail.ru ; Gerrit de Bruijn
Sent: Sunday, May 14, 2006 11:52 PM
Subject: PWCE
Dear Mr. J.Bus, dear Mr. J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD has not made of any decision concerning Mr. J.Ceron (PWCE): there was no voting, there is no report of the decision on this question, opinions of members CPI on this question dispatch. The decision was accepted by one person - Mr. J.Bus.
2. From judges PWCE Mr. P.Shkludov, Mr. R.Mackevicius I have learned, that Mr. J.Ceron, being based on decision Mr. J.Bus, without the coordination with judges, have changed their estimations to some positions PWCE (as estimations I are changed do not know and I do not wish to know). The specified judges protest. Estimations are changed WITHOUT the COORDINATION With JUDGES And WITHOUT DECISION CPI FMJD. It is not stipulated neither in RI CPI FMJD, nor in Rules PWCE. It is inadmissible and I make the protest.
3. I consider, that the announcement of preliminary results without discussion of the given fact and the given situation in CPI and, probably, in CD FMJD or GA FMJD, impossible.
4. I am compelled to send this letter and to the first âèöå to president FMJD, me very dear Mr. P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.J.Bus, dear Mr.J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD íå ïðèíÿëà íèêàêîãî ðåøåíèÿ ïî âîïðîñàì Mr.J.Ceron (PWCE): íå áûëî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ, íåò ïðîòîêîëà ðåøåíèÿ ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó, ìíåíèÿ ÷ëåíîâ CPI ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó ðàçîøëèñü. Ðåøåíèå ïðèíÿë îäèí ÷åëîâåê - Mr.J.Bus.
2. Îò ñóäåé PWCE Mr.P.Shkludov, Mr.R.Mackevicius ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî Mr.J.Ceron, îñíîâûâàÿñü íà ðåøåíèå Mr.J.Bus, áåç ñîãëàñîâàíèÿ ñ ñóäüÿìè, ïîìåíÿë èõ îöåíêè íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE (êàê èçìåíåíû îöåíêè ÿ íå çíàþ è íå õî÷ó çíàòü). Óêàçàííûå ñóäüè ïðîòåñòóþò. Îöåíêè èçìåíåíû ÁÅÇ ÑÎÃËÀÑÎÂÀÍÈß Ñ ÑÓÄÜßÌÈ È ÁÅÇ ÐÅØÅÍÈß CPI FMJD. Ýòî íå ïðåäóñìîòðåíî íè â RI CPI FMJD, íè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE. Ýòî íåäîïóñòèìî è ÿ âûðàæàþ ñâîé ïðîòåñò.
3. ß ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî îáúÿâëåíèå ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ áåç îáñóæäåíèÿ äàííîãî ôàêòà è äàííîé ñèòóàöèè â CPI è, âîçìîæíî, â CD FMJD èëè GA FMJD, íåâîçìîæíîå.
4. Ýòî ïèñüìî ÿ âûíóæäåí îòïðàâèòü è ïåðâîìó âèöå ïðåçèäåíòó FMJD, ìíîþ î÷åíü óâàæàåìîìó Mr.P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
3. After 14 – 05 – 2006 I have learned, that J.Bus other member CPI Mr. V.Matus (but, I repeat, no voting and any report CPI FMJD existed and is not present) has partially supported and that Mr. P.Shkludov has executed requirement Mr. J.Bus - has exposed estimations to disputable positions. After that I have decided to not protest any more (as refereeing and the announcement of results PWCE very much was late), but have declared, that after the announcement of preliminary results PWCE, I all òàêè shall officially set a question on the basis of what documents there were changes zero estimations Mr. R.Mackevicius.
4. After the announcement of preliminary results I from judges PWCE have learned, that without their consent are changed not only estimations Mr. R.Mackevicius, but estimations Mr. P.Shkludov are essentially overestimated also! Change of estimations Mr. P.Shkludov in CPI was not discussed at all. I support conclusion Mr. R.Mackevicius and Mr. P.Shkludov, that it is falsification of results PWCE.
5. Under request Mr. R.Mackevicius and Mr. P.Shkludov I sendand their application.
Algimantas Kaciuska member CPI FMJD
05 – 06 – 2006
ÎÒÊÐÛÒÛÅ ÎÁÐÀÙÅÍÈß
Ãëóáîêîóâàæàåìûé Ïðåçèäåíò FMJD,
óâàæàåìûå ãîñïîäà, äîðîãèå êîëëåãè,
I. ÇÀßÂËÅÍÈÅ ÑÓÄÅÉ PERSONAL WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP END – GAME (PWCE) R.MACKEVICIUS è P.SHKLUDOV
Íà ñàéòå FMJD ïðåçèäåíò Committee of the Problemism International (CPI) FMJD Mr.J.Bus îáúÿâèë ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå ðåçóëüòàòû Personal World Championship End – games (PWCE).
Ìû, 2 ñóäåé PWCE (âñåãî â PWCE ñóäèëè 3 ñóäüè), ïðîòåñòóåì ïðîòèâ ôàëüñèôèêàöèè ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE:
1.  PWCE åñòü íåñêîëüêî ïîçèöèè, â êîòîðûõ îäíè ñóäüè ïîçèöèè äàþò î÷êè, äðóãèå ñóäüè äàþò 0 î÷êîâ. Mr.J.Bus ÷åðåç êîîðäèíàòîðà PWCE Mr.J.Ceron íà÷àë äàâëåíèå íà ñóäåé, ÷òîáû ìû ýòè ýòþäàì èçìåíèëè ñâîè íóëåâûå îöåíêè íà ïîëîæèòåëüíûå îöåíêè.  èòîãå:
1.1. Ñóäüÿ R.Mackevicius íå èçìåíèë ñâîèõ íóëåâûõ îöåíîê.
1.2. Ñóäüÿ P.Shkludov óêàçàë íà ïóíêòû Regles Internationales (RI) CPI FMJD, ñîãëàñíî êîòîðûõ êîìïîçèöèè äîëæíû áûëè ïîëó÷èòü íóëåâûå îöåíêè. Íî, âèäÿ, ÷òî ýòà èíôîðìàöèÿ Mr.J.Bus íå èíòåðåñóåò, äàë ýòèì ïîçèöèÿì ìèíèìàëüíûå îöåíêè (01 – 02 î÷êà â 100 î÷êîâîé øêàëå).
2. Ïî îáúÿâëåííûì ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûì ðåçóëüòàòàì PWCE ìû âèäèì, ÷òî Mr.J.Bus, áåç íàøåãî ñîãëàñèÿ, èçìåíèë íàøè îöåíêè è ýòèì ïîçèöèÿì äàë çíà÷èòåëüíî áîëåå âûñîêèå îöåíêè, ïîìåíÿâ íàøè íóëåâûå è ìèíèìàëüíûå îöåíêè.  ñâÿçè ñ ýòèì ìû ñïðàøèâàåì:
Ãäå â RI CPI FMJD èëè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE íàïèñàíî, ÷òî ïðåçèäåíò CPI FMJD, CPI FMJD, êîîðäèíàòîð PWCE èëè äðóãîå ëèöî ìîæåò ìåíÿòü îöåíêè ñóäåé PWCE?
3.  èòîãå 2 ïîçèöèè PWCE, êîòîðûì ïîëîæèòåëüíûå, ñðàâíèòåëüíî âûñîêèå îöåíêè äàë òîëüêî ñóäüÿ PWCE Mr.G.L.de Bruijn, à ìû äàëè 0 è 01, 02 î÷êà, ïîñëå èçìåíåíèÿ áåç íàøåãî ñîãëàñèÿ íàøèõ îöåíîê íà îöåíêè â óðîâíå 30 – 50 î÷êîâ, â ñâîèõ êàòåãîðèÿõ çàíÿëè î÷åíü âûñîêèå 6 è 10 ìåñòà. Ýòî ìîæåò èìåòü ðåøàþùåå âëèÿíèå íà ðàñïðåäåëåíèå èòîãîâûõ ìåñò íà PWCE.
Ìû íå èìååì ïðàâà îáúÿâèòü ïîäðîáíîñòè (íîìåðà êîíêðåòíûõ ïîçèöèè, áîëåå êîíêðåòíûå îöåíêè è ò.ä.), òàê êàê ýòî áóäåò íàðóøåíèåì RI FMJD CPI â îòíîøåíèå ïðîâåäåíèÿ ñîðåâíîâàíèé. Äî îáúÿâëåíèÿ èòîãîâûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE íåëüçÿ ðàçãëàøàòü ïîäîáíóþ èíôîðìàöèþ. Íî ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ îêîí÷àòåëüíûõ èòîãîâ óæå áóäåò ïîçäíî.
Rimas Mackevicius ñóäüÿ PWCE
Piotr Shkludov ñóäüÿ PWCE
03 – 06 – 2006
II. ÇÀßÂËÅÍÈÅ ×ËÅÍÀ CPI FMJD A.KACIUSKA
1. Âîïðîñ èçìåíåíèÿ íóëåâûõ îöåíîê íåêîòîðûõ ñóäåé íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE îáñóæäàëñÿ â CPI FMJD. Íèêàêîãî ïðîòîêîëà CPI FMJD, íèêàêîãî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ ïî ýòèì âîïðîñàì íå áûëî è íåò. ß âñåãäà áûë ïðîòèâ èçìåíåíèÿ îöåíîê ñóäåé áåç èõ ñîãëàñèÿ. Ñîçíàþ, ÷òî òàêèå ïðåöåäåíòû áûëè è åñòü â äðóãèõ âèäàõ ñïîðòà, íî ïîðÿäîê ïîäîáíûõ àïåëëÿöèè, èçìåíåíèè äîëæåí áûòü îïðåäåëåí â ñîîòâåòñòâóþùèõ äîêóìåíòàõ äî íà÷àëà ñîðåâíîâàíèè.
2. 14 – 05 - 2006 ÿ íàïðàâèë ñëåäóþùåå ïèñüìî:
Original Message -----
From: Algimantas
To: jaapbus@t-online.de ; hiltex@wxs.nl ; vpmatus@rambler.ru ; Intlegal@Rim2000.ru
Cc: Jacques Ceron ; Rimas ; shkludov@mail.ru ; Gerrit de Bruijn
Sent: Sunday, May 14, 2006 11:52 PM
Subject: PWCE
Dear Mr. J.Bus, dear Mr. J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD has not made of any decision concerning Mr. J.Ceron (PWCE): there was no voting, there is no report of the decision on this question, opinions of members CPI on this question dispatch. The decision was accepted by one person - Mr. J.Bus.
2. From judges PWCE Mr. P.Shkludov, Mr. R.Mackevicius I have learned, that Mr. J.Ceron, being based on decision Mr. J.Bus, without the coordination with judges, have changed their estimations to some positions PWCE (as estimations I are changed do not know and I do not wish to know). The specified judges protest. Estimations are changed WITHOUT the COORDINATION With JUDGES And WITHOUT DECISION CPI FMJD. It is not stipulated neither in RI CPI FMJD, nor in Rules PWCE. It is inadmissible and I make the protest.
3. I consider, that the announcement of preliminary results without discussion of the given fact and the given situation in CPI and, probably, in CD FMJD or GA FMJD, impossible.
4. I am compelled to send this letter and to the first âèöå to president FMJD, me very dear Mr. P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.J.Bus, dear Mr.J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD íå ïðèíÿëà íèêàêîãî ðåøåíèÿ ïî âîïðîñàì Mr.J.Ceron (PWCE): íå áûëî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ, íåò ïðîòîêîëà ðåøåíèÿ ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó, ìíåíèÿ ÷ëåíîâ CPI ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó ðàçîøëèñü. Ðåøåíèå ïðèíÿë îäèí ÷åëîâåê - Mr.J.Bus.
2. Îò ñóäåé PWCE Mr.P.Shkludov, Mr.R.Mackevicius ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî Mr.J.Ceron, îñíîâûâàÿñü íà ðåøåíèå Mr.J.Bus, áåç ñîãëàñîâàíèÿ ñ ñóäüÿìè, ïîìåíÿë èõ îöåíêè íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE (êàê èçìåíåíû îöåíêè ÿ íå çíàþ è íå õî÷ó çíàòü). Óêàçàííûå ñóäüè ïðîòåñòóþò. Îöåíêè èçìåíåíû ÁÅÇ ÑÎÃËÀÑÎÂÀÍÈß Ñ ÑÓÄÜßÌÈ È ÁÅÇ ÐÅØÅÍÈß CPI FMJD. Ýòî íå ïðåäóñìîòðåíî íè â RI CPI FMJD, íè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE. Ýòî íåäîïóñòèìî è ÿ âûðàæàþ ñâîé ïðîòåñò.
3. ß ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî îáúÿâëåíèå ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ áåç îáñóæäåíèÿ äàííîãî ôàêòà è äàííîé ñèòóàöèè â CPI è, âîçìîæíî, â CD FMJD èëè GA FMJD, íåâîçìîæíîå.
4. Ýòî ïèñüìî ÿ âûíóæäåí îòïðàâèòü è ïåðâîìó âèöå ïðåçèäåíòó FMJD, ìíîþ î÷åíü óâàæàåìîìó Mr.P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
3. Ïîñëå 14 – 05 – 2006 ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî J.Bus ÷àñòè÷íî ïîääåðæàë äðóãîé ÷ëåí CPI Mr.V.Matus (íî, ïîâòîðÿþ, íèêàêîãî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ è íèêàêîãî ïðîòîêîëà CPI FMJD íå áûëî è íåò) è ÷òî Mr.P.Shkludov âûïîëíèë òðåáîâàíèå Mr.J.Bus - âûñòàâèë îöåíêè ñïîðíûì ïîçèöèÿì. Ïîñëå ýòîãî ÿ ðåøèë áîëüøå íå ïðîòåñòîâàòü (òàê êàê ñóäåéñòâî è îáúÿâëåíèå ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE î÷åíü çàäåðæàëîñü), íî çàÿâèë, ÷òî ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ PWCE, ÿ âñå òàêè îôèöèàëüíî çàäàì âîïðîñ íà îñíîâå êàêèõ äîêóìåíòîâ áûëè èçìåíû íóëåâûå îöåíêè Mr.R.Mackevicius.
4. Ïîñëå îáúÿâëåíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ ÿ îò ñóäåé PWCE óçíàë, ÷òî áåç èõ ñîãëàñèÿ èçìåíåíû íå òîëüêî îöåíêè Mr.R.Mackevicius, íî ñóùåñòâåííî çàâûøåíû è îöåíêè Mr.P.Shkludov! Èçìåíåíèå îöåíîê Mr.P.Shkludov â CPI âîîáùå íå îáñóæäàëîñü. ß ïîääåðæèâàþ âûâîä Mr.R.Mackevicius è Mr.P.Shkludov, ÷òî ýòî – ôàëüñèôèêàöèÿ èòîãîâ PWCE.
5. Ïî ïðîñüáå Mr.R.Mackevicius è Mr.P.Shkludov ÿ ðàñïîñòðàíÿþ è èõ çàÿâëåíèå.
Algimantas Kaciuska ÷ëåí CPI FMJD
05 – 06 – 2006
-------------------------------------------------
(êîìïüþòåðíûé ïåðåâîä íà àíãëèéñêèé)
-------------------------------------------------
THE OPEN REFERENCES
Dear President FMJD,
Dear sirs, dear colleagues,
I. The APPLICATION of JUDGES PERSONAL WORLD CHAMPIONSHIP END – GAME (PWCE) R.MACKEVICIUS and P.SHKLUDOV
On site FMJD president Committee of the Problemism International (CPI) FMJD Mr. J.Bus has declared preliminary results Personal World Championship End – games (PWCE).
We, 2 judges PWCE (all in PWCE 3 judges judged), protest against falsification of results PWCE:
1. In PWCE there is some position in which one judges of a position give glasses, other judges give 0 glasses. Mr. J.Bus through coordinator PWCE Mr. J.Ceron has begun pressure upon judges that we these to etudes have changed the zero estimations to positive estimations. As a result:
1.1. Judge R.Mackevicius has not changed the zero estimations.
1.2. Judge P.Shkludov has specified items Regles Internationales (RI) CPI FMJD according to which compositions should were to receive zero estimations. But, seeing, that this information Mr. J.Bus does not interest, has given these positions the minimal estimations (01 – 02 spots in 100 a scale).
2. By declared preliminary results PWCE we see, that Mr. J.Bus, without our consent, has changed our estimations and to these positions has given much higher estimations, having changed our zero and minimal estimations. In this connection we ask:
Where in RI CPI FMJD or in Rules PWCE it is written, what president CPI FMJD, CPI FMJD, coordinator PWCE or other person can change estimations of judges PWCE?
3. As a result of 2 positions PWCE to which positive, rather high estimations were given only by judge PWCE Mr. G.L.de Bruijn, and we have given 0 and 01, 02 spots, after change without our consent of our estimations to estimations in a level 30 – 50 glasses, in the categories have borrowed very high 6 and 10 places. It can have solving influence on distribution of final places on PWCE.
We have no right to declare a detail (number concrete a position, more concrete estimations, etc.) as it will be infringement RI FMJD CPI in the attitude of carrying out of competitions. Up to the announcement of final results PWCE it is impossible to disclose the similar information. But after the announcement of adjusted totals already will be late.
Rimas Mackevicius judge PWCE
Piotr Shkludov judgePWCE
03 – 06 – 2006
II. THE APPLICATION OF MEMBER CPI FMJD A.KACIUSKA
1. The question of change of zero estimations of some judges to some positions PWCE was discussed in CPI FMJD. Any report CPI FMJD, no voting on these questions existed and is not present. I always was against change of estimations of judges without their consent. I understand, that such precedents were and there is in other kinds of sports, but an order similar to the appeal, change should be certain in corresponding documents prior to the beginning competition.
2.14 – 05 - 2006 I have sent the following letter:
Original Message -----
From: Algimantas
To: jaapbus@t-online.de ; hiltex@wxs.nl ; vpmatus@rambler.ru ; Intlegal@Rim2000.ru
Cc: Jacques Ceron ; Rimas ; shkludov@mail.ru ; Gerrit de Bruijn
Sent: Sunday, May 14, 2006 11:52 PM
Subject: PWCE
Dear Mr. J.Bus, dear Mr. J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD has not made of any decision concerning Mr. J.Ceron (PWCE): there was no voting, there is no report of the decision on this question, opinions of members CPI on this question dispatch. The decision was accepted by one person - Mr. J.Bus.
2. From judges PWCE Mr. P.Shkludov, Mr. R.Mackevicius I have learned, that Mr. J.Ceron, being based on decision Mr. J.Bus, without the coordination with judges, have changed their estimations to some positions PWCE (as estimations I are changed do not know and I do not wish to know). The specified judges protest. Estimations are changed WITHOUT the COORDINATION With JUDGES And WITHOUT DECISION CPI FMJD. It is not stipulated neither in RI CPI FMJD, nor in Rules PWCE. It is inadmissible and I make the protest.
3. I consider, that the announcement of preliminary results without discussion of the given fact and the given situation in CPI and, probably, in CD FMJD or GA FMJD, impossible.
4. I am compelled to send this letter and to the first âèöå to president FMJD, me very dear Mr. P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.J.Bus, dear Mr.J.Ceron, dear gentlemen,
1. CPI FMJD íå ïðèíÿëà íèêàêîãî ðåøåíèÿ ïî âîïðîñàì Mr.J.Ceron (PWCE): íå áûëî ãîëîñîâàíèÿ, íåò ïðîòîêîëà ðåøåíèÿ ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó, ìíåíèÿ ÷ëåíîâ CPI ïî ýòîìó âîïðîñó ðàçîøëèñü. Ðåøåíèå ïðèíÿë îäèí ÷åëîâåê - Mr.J.Bus.
2. Îò ñóäåé PWCE Mr.P.Shkludov, Mr.R.Mackevicius ÿ óçíàë, ÷òî Mr.J.Ceron, îñíîâûâàÿñü íà ðåøåíèå Mr.J.Bus, áåç ñîãëàñîâàíèÿ ñ ñóäüÿìè, ïîìåíÿë èõ îöåíêè íåêîòîðûì ïîçèöèÿì PWCE (êàê èçìåíåíû îöåíêè ÿ íå çíàþ è íå õî÷ó çíàòü). Óêàçàííûå ñóäüè ïðîòåñòóþò. Îöåíêè èçìåíåíû ÁÅÇ ÑÎÃËÀÑÎÂÀÍÈß Ñ ÑÓÄÜßÌÈ È ÁÅÇ ÐÅØÅÍÈß CPI FMJD. Ýòî íå ïðåäóñìîòðåíî íè â RI CPI FMJD, íè â Ðåãëàìåíòå PWCE. Ýòî íåäîïóñòèìî è ÿ âûðàæàþ ñâîé ïðîòåñò.
3. ß ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî îáúÿâëåíèå ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ ðåçóëüòàòîâ áåç îáñóæäåíèÿ äàííîãî ôàêòà è äàííîé ñèòóàöèè â CPI è, âîçìîæíî, â CD FMJD èëè GA FMJD, íåâîçìîæíîå.
4. Ýòî ïèñüìî ÿ âûíóæäåí îòïðàâèòü è ïåðâîìó âèöå ïðåçèäåíòó FMJD, ìíîþ î÷åíü óâàæàåìîìó Mr.P.Hildering.
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
3. After 14 – 05 – 2006 I have learned, that J.Bus other member CPI Mr. V.Matus (but, I repeat, no voting and any report CPI FMJD existed and is not present) has partially supported and that Mr. P.Shkludov has executed requirement Mr. J.Bus - has exposed estimations to disputable positions. After that I have decided to not protest any more (as refereeing and the announcement of results PWCE very much was late), but have declared, that after the announcement of preliminary results PWCE, I all òàêè shall officially set a question on the basis of what documents there were changes zero estimations Mr. R.Mackevicius.
4. After the announcement of preliminary results I from judges PWCE have learned, that without their consent are changed not only estimations Mr. R.Mackevicius, but estimations Mr. P.Shkludov are essentially overestimated also! Change of estimations Mr. P.Shkludov in CPI was not discussed at all. I support conclusion Mr. R.Mackevicius and Mr. P.Shkludov, that it is falsification of results PWCE.
5. Under request Mr. R.Mackevicius and Mr. P.Shkludov I sendand their application.
Algimantas Kaciuska member CPI FMJD
05 – 06 – 2006
-
Guest
Äëÿ òîãî ÷òîáû õîòÿ áû êàê-òî ïðåäñòàâèòü ñåáå, èç-çà ÷åãî «ðàçãîðåëñÿ ñûð áîð», ÿ ïðåäîñòàâëÿþ Âàøåìó âíèìàíèþ óïðîùåííûå ïðèìåðû.
ß âûñòàâèë çà ïîäîáíîå «òâîð÷åñòâî» íóëè.
Áóñ «íàñòîé÷èâî ðåêîìåíäîâàë» âûñòàâèòü îöåíêè è íèêàêèå àðãóìåíòû åãî íåâîëíîâàëè.
1.
Çà ñ÷åò äîáàâëåíèÿ ìàòåðèàëà, ïîêàçàíî âñòóïëåíèå ê èçâåñòíîìó ýòþäó, áåç îáîãàùåíèÿ ñîäåðæàíèÿ íîâûìè ÊÂ, èëè ËÑ.
à3(d4), å5, c3, f8 – Í. Ïàíêðàòîâ ÀÍÒ.64-1-14.
Äî ýòþäà Í. Ïàíêðàòîâà íèêàêèõ ÊÂ èëè ËÑ íåò.
2.
Áåç äîáàâëåíèÿ ìàòåðèàëà, ïîêàçàíî âñòóïëåíèå ê èçâåñòíîìó ýòþäó, áåç îáîãàùåíèÿ ñîäåðæàíèÿ íîâûìè ÊÂ, èëè ËÑ.
f4(c7), e5(b6), d6(a5) – Þãåíåí, ÀÍÒ.64-1-67.
Äî ýòþäà Þðãåíåíà íèêàêèõ ÊÂ èëè ËÑ íåò.
3.
Èçâåñòíàÿ ñõåìà ïðèìåíåíà íà äðóãîì ó÷àñòêå äîñêè.
À. Êèðèëëîâ, ÀÍÒ.64-1-943
Ë. Òåâàí, ÀÍÒ.64-1-943à
ß âûñòàâèë çà ïîäîáíîå «òâîð÷åñòâî» íóëè.
Áóñ «íàñòîé÷èâî ðåêîìåíäîâàë» âûñòàâèòü îöåíêè è íèêàêèå àðãóìåíòû åãî íåâîëíîâàëè.
1.
Çà ñ÷åò äîáàâëåíèÿ ìàòåðèàëà, ïîêàçàíî âñòóïëåíèå ê èçâåñòíîìó ýòþäó, áåç îáîãàùåíèÿ ñîäåðæàíèÿ íîâûìè ÊÂ, èëè ËÑ.
à3(d4), å5, c3, f8 – Í. Ïàíêðàòîâ ÀÍÒ.64-1-14.
Äî ýòþäà Í. Ïàíêðàòîâà íèêàêèõ ÊÂ èëè ËÑ íåò.
2.
Áåç äîáàâëåíèÿ ìàòåðèàëà, ïîêàçàíî âñòóïëåíèå ê èçâåñòíîìó ýòþäó, áåç îáîãàùåíèÿ ñîäåðæàíèÿ íîâûìè ÊÂ, èëè ËÑ.
f4(c7), e5(b6), d6(a5) – Þãåíåí, ÀÍÒ.64-1-67.
Äî ýòþäà Þðãåíåíà íèêàêèõ ÊÂ èëè ËÑ íåò.
3.
Èçâåñòíàÿ ñõåìà ïðèìåíåíà íà äðóãîì ó÷àñòêå äîñêè.
À. Êèðèëëîâ, ÀÍÒ.64-1-943
Ë. Òåâàí, ÀÍÒ.64-1-943à
-
Guest
Îøèáêè ãîñïîäèíà Áóñà ïðîäîëæàþòñÿ.
ß äàæå êàê-òî ñðàçó íå îáðàòèë âíèìàíèÿ...
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ ÍÈÃÄÅ ÍÅ ÁÛËÈ ÎÏÓÁËÈÊÎÂÀÍÛ çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ýòþäàì PWCE!... È êàê òåïåðü ó÷àñòíèêàì äàâàòü ÏÐÎÒÅÑÒÛ???
×èòàéòå åùå îäíî çàÿâëåíèå À. Êà÷þøêè: 2006-06-10 14:59
http://plus.gambler.ru/phpbb/viewtopic. ... rt=200&213
Dear Mr. Jaap Bus,
Allow to notice to you, that Personal World Championship End – Game (PWCE) it is spent VERY badly. In CPI personally you have undertaken to coordinate carrying out of this championship, some times emphasizing, that till now, on yours and in opinion of your Dutch colleagues, the international competitions on a composition were spent very badly.
01 – 06 – 2006 preliminary results PWCE (by the way, under rules PWCE they should be published not only on sites FMJD, TAVLEI, but also on site E.Dusseldorp are declared. There they still are not present.). Also it is declared (correctly, on Regles Internationales CPI FMJD): « The jury accepts protests and objections of participants - within a month, that is not later on July, 01st 2006 ã ». But ANYWHERE THE JURY (THE COORDINATOR) HAVE NOT DECLARED REMARKS TO ETUDES , made by judges, participants PWCE, composers. Remarks also are not dispatched and personally to participants PWCE (for example, 09 – 06 – 2006 has received the information, that one very known composer, I think, the applicant for prize-winning places in PWCE, not having the remark, has no opportunities to protest one zero estimation to the product. Also does not understand, that occurs in PWCE). In RI CPI FMJD it is written: «L’appel sera seulement considéré si l’auteur pense que le défaut analytique dénoncé par le jury n’est pas correct.» (fr., 2.5. RI CPI FMJD). But in this case, how participants PWCE can protest, if they do not have even the minimal information, absolutely any analysis? And still. As all remarks publicly (and even personally) are not declared, whether authors the remark can be assured, what remarks are finished by all of them to judges PWCE?
Spending “ Lietuva – 2001 ” and “ Lietuva – 2003 ” (at carrying out of earlier competitions yet was not øàøå÷íûõ web – site) I all the received remarks published competitions EVEN BEFORE publication of preliminary results. From Mr. A.Tavernier has heard reproaches, that they too detailed, etc. From Mr. S.Yushkevitch has heard charges that was not the remark to two positions to which on one judge have stated a zero estimation. I accept criticism, I analyze, I do conclusions.
In later competitions ("RETRO" and « Memorial S.de Bruijn ”) their organizers of the remark have declared , declaring preliminary results. I consider, that it too is more less normal.
Now we go further. Remarks do not appear at all. “It fine” … Up to the announcement of ADJUSTED TOTALS of any protests. But to whom it is favourable?
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.Jaap Bus,
Ðàçðåøèòå Âàì çàìåòèòü, ÷òî Personal World Championship End – Game (PWCE) ïðîâîäèòñÿ Î×ÅÍÜ ïëîõî.  CPI ëè÷íî Âû âçÿëèñü êîîðäèíèðîâàòü ïðîâåäåíèå ýòîãî ÷åìïèîíàòà, íåñêîëüêî ðàç ïîä÷åðêèâàÿ, ÷òî äî ñèõ ïîð, ïî Âàøåìó è ïî ìíåíèþ Âàøèõ ãîëëàíäñêèõ êîëëåã, ìåæäóíàðîäíûå ñîðåâíîâàíèÿ ïî êîìïîçèöèè ïðîâîäèëèñü î÷åíü ïëîõî.
01 – 06 – 2006 îáúÿâëåíû ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE (êñòàòè, ïî ðåãëàìåíòó PWCE îíè äîëæíû áûëè áûòü îïóáëèêîâàíû íå òîëüêî íà ñàéòàõ FMJD, TAVLEI, íî è íà ñàéòå E.Dusseldorp. Òàì èõ åùå íåò.). È îáúÿâëåíî (ïðàâèëüíî, ïî Regles Internationales CPI FMJD): «Æþðè ïðèíèìàåò ïðîòåñòû è âîçðàæåíèÿ ó÷àñòíèêîâ - â òå÷åíèå ìåñÿöà, òî åñòü íå ïîçäíåå 01 èþëÿ 2006 ã». Íî ÍÈÃÄÅ ÆÞÐÈ (ÊÎÎÐÄÈÍÀÒÎÐ) ÍÅ ÎÁÚßÂÈËÈ ÇÀÌÅ×ÀÍÈÈÉ Ê ÝÒÞÄÀÌ, ñäåëàííûå ñóäüÿìè, ó÷àñòíèêàìè PWCE, êîìïîçèòîðàìè. Çàìå÷àíèÿ òàêæå íå ðàçîñëàíû è ïåðñîíàëüíî ó÷àñòíèêàì PWCE (íàïðèìåð, 09 – 06 – 2006 ïîëó÷èë èíôîðìàöèþ, ÷òî îäèí î÷åíü èçâåñòíûé êîìïîçèòîð, äóìàþ, ïðåòåíäåíò íà ïðèçîâûå ìåñòà â PWCE, íå èìåÿ çàìå÷àíèè, íå èìååò âîçìîæíîñòåé çàïðîòåñòîâàòü îäíó íóëåâóþ îöåíêó ñâîåìó ïðîèçâåäåíèþ. È íå ïîíèìàåò, ÷òî ïðîèñõîäèò â PWCE).  RI CPI FMJD íàïèñàíî: «Ïðîòåñò ðàññìàòðèâàåòñÿ òîëüêî â ñëó÷àå, åñëè àâòîð ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî äåôåêò â àíàëèçå, óêàçàííûé æþðè, íà ñàìîì äåëå íå ÿâëÿåòñÿ äåôåêòîì.» (RI CPI FMJD, ïóíêò 2.5.) Íî â äàííîì ñëó÷àå, êàê ó÷àñòíèêè PWCE ìîãóò ïðîòåñòîâàòü, åñëè ó íèõ íåò äàæå ìèíèìàëüíîé èíôîðìàöèè, àáñîëþòíî íèêàêîãî àíàëèçà? È åùå. Òàê êàê âñå çàìå÷àíèÿ ïóáëè÷íî (è äàæå ïåðñîíàëüíî) ÍÅ ÎÁÚßÂËÅÍÛ, ìîãóò ëè áûòü óâåðåíû àâòîðû çàìå÷àíèè, ÷òî âñå èõ çàìå÷àíèÿ äîâåäåíû äî ñóäåé PWCE?
Ïðîâîäÿ êîíêóðñû “Lietuva – 2001” è “Lietuva – 2003”(ïðè ïðîâåäåíèè áîëåå ðàííèõ êîíêóðñîâ åùå íå áûëî øàøå÷íûõ web – site) ÿ âñå ïîëó÷åííûå çàìå÷àíèÿ ïóáëèêîâàë ÅÙÅ ÄÎ îïóáëèêîâàíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ èòîãîâ. Îò Mr.A.Tavernier óñëûøàë óïðåêè, ÷òî îíè ñëèøêîì ïîäðîáíûå è ò.ï. Îò Mr.S.Yushkevitch óñëûøàë îáâèíåíèÿ, ÷òî íå áûëî çàìå÷àíèè ê äâóì ïîçèöèÿì, êîòîðûì ïî îäíîìó ñóäüè äàëè íóëåâóþ îöåíêó. Êðèòèêó ÿ ïðèíèìàþ, àíàëèçèðóþ, äåëàþ âûâîäû.
 áîëåå ïîçäíèõ êîíêóðñàõ («Ðåòðî» è «Memorial S.de Bruijn”) èõ îðãàíèçàòîðû çàìå÷àíèÿ îáúÿâèëè, îáúÿâëÿÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè. Ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî ýòî òîæå áîëåå ìåíåå íîðìàëüíî.
Òåïåðü èäåì äàëüøå. Çàìå÷àíèÿ âîîáùå íå îáúÿâëÿþòñÿ. «Ïðåêðàñíî»…Äî îáúÿâëåíèÿ ÎÊÎÍ×ÀÒÅËÜÍÛÕ èòîãîâ íå áóäåò íèêàêèõ ïðîòåñòîâ. Íî êîìó ýòî âûãîäíî?
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
ß äàæå êàê-òî ñðàçó íå îáðàòèë âíèìàíèÿ...
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ ÍÈÃÄÅ ÍÅ ÁÛËÈ ÎÏÓÁËÈÊÎÂÀÍÛ çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ýòþäàì PWCE!... È êàê òåïåðü ó÷àñòíèêàì äàâàòü ÏÐÎÒÅÑÒÛ???
×èòàéòå åùå îäíî çàÿâëåíèå À. Êà÷þøêè: 2006-06-10 14:59
http://plus.gambler.ru/phpbb/viewtopic. ... rt=200&213
Dear Mr. Jaap Bus,
Allow to notice to you, that Personal World Championship End – Game (PWCE) it is spent VERY badly. In CPI personally you have undertaken to coordinate carrying out of this championship, some times emphasizing, that till now, on yours and in opinion of your Dutch colleagues, the international competitions on a composition were spent very badly.
01 – 06 – 2006 preliminary results PWCE (by the way, under rules PWCE they should be published not only on sites FMJD, TAVLEI, but also on site E.Dusseldorp are declared. There they still are not present.). Also it is declared (correctly, on Regles Internationales CPI FMJD): « The jury accepts protests and objections of participants - within a month, that is not later on July, 01st 2006 ã ». But ANYWHERE THE JURY (THE COORDINATOR) HAVE NOT DECLARED REMARKS TO ETUDES , made by judges, participants PWCE, composers. Remarks also are not dispatched and personally to participants PWCE (for example, 09 – 06 – 2006 has received the information, that one very known composer, I think, the applicant for prize-winning places in PWCE, not having the remark, has no opportunities to protest one zero estimation to the product. Also does not understand, that occurs in PWCE). In RI CPI FMJD it is written: «L’appel sera seulement considéré si l’auteur pense que le défaut analytique dénoncé par le jury n’est pas correct.» (fr., 2.5. RI CPI FMJD). But in this case, how participants PWCE can protest, if they do not have even the minimal information, absolutely any analysis? And still. As all remarks publicly (and even personally) are not declared, whether authors the remark can be assured, what remarks are finished by all of them to judges PWCE?
Spending “ Lietuva – 2001 ” and “ Lietuva – 2003 ” (at carrying out of earlier competitions yet was not øàøå÷íûõ web – site) I all the received remarks published competitions EVEN BEFORE publication of preliminary results. From Mr. A.Tavernier has heard reproaches, that they too detailed, etc. From Mr. S.Yushkevitch has heard charges that was not the remark to two positions to which on one judge have stated a zero estimation. I accept criticism, I analyze, I do conclusions.
In later competitions ("RETRO" and « Memorial S.de Bruijn ”) their organizers of the remark have declared , declaring preliminary results. I consider, that it too is more less normal.
Now we go further. Remarks do not appear at all. “It fine” … Up to the announcement of ADJUSTED TOTALS of any protests. But to whom it is favourable?
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
Dear Mr.Jaap Bus,
Ðàçðåøèòå Âàì çàìåòèòü, ÷òî Personal World Championship End – Game (PWCE) ïðîâîäèòñÿ Î×ÅÍÜ ïëîõî.  CPI ëè÷íî Âû âçÿëèñü êîîðäèíèðîâàòü ïðîâåäåíèå ýòîãî ÷åìïèîíàòà, íåñêîëüêî ðàç ïîä÷åðêèâàÿ, ÷òî äî ñèõ ïîð, ïî Âàøåìó è ïî ìíåíèþ Âàøèõ ãîëëàíäñêèõ êîëëåã, ìåæäóíàðîäíûå ñîðåâíîâàíèÿ ïî êîìïîçèöèè ïðîâîäèëèñü î÷åíü ïëîõî.
01 – 06 – 2006 îáúÿâëåíû ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE (êñòàòè, ïî ðåãëàìåíòó PWCE îíè äîëæíû áûëè áûòü îïóáëèêîâàíû íå òîëüêî íà ñàéòàõ FMJD, TAVLEI, íî è íà ñàéòå E.Dusseldorp. Òàì èõ åùå íåò.). È îáúÿâëåíî (ïðàâèëüíî, ïî Regles Internationales CPI FMJD): «Æþðè ïðèíèìàåò ïðîòåñòû è âîçðàæåíèÿ ó÷àñòíèêîâ - â òå÷åíèå ìåñÿöà, òî åñòü íå ïîçäíåå 01 èþëÿ 2006 ã». Íî ÍÈÃÄÅ ÆÞÐÈ (ÊÎÎÐÄÈÍÀÒÎÐ) ÍÅ ÎÁÚßÂÈËÈ ÇÀÌÅ×ÀÍÈÈÉ Ê ÝÒÞÄÀÌ, ñäåëàííûå ñóäüÿìè, ó÷àñòíèêàìè PWCE, êîìïîçèòîðàìè. Çàìå÷àíèÿ òàêæå íå ðàçîñëàíû è ïåðñîíàëüíî ó÷àñòíèêàì PWCE (íàïðèìåð, 09 – 06 – 2006 ïîëó÷èë èíôîðìàöèþ, ÷òî îäèí î÷åíü èçâåñòíûé êîìïîçèòîð, äóìàþ, ïðåòåíäåíò íà ïðèçîâûå ìåñòà â PWCE, íå èìåÿ çàìå÷àíèè, íå èìååò âîçìîæíîñòåé çàïðîòåñòîâàòü îäíó íóëåâóþ îöåíêó ñâîåìó ïðîèçâåäåíèþ. È íå ïîíèìàåò, ÷òî ïðîèñõîäèò â PWCE).  RI CPI FMJD íàïèñàíî: «Ïðîòåñò ðàññìàòðèâàåòñÿ òîëüêî â ñëó÷àå, åñëè àâòîð ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî äåôåêò â àíàëèçå, óêàçàííûé æþðè, íà ñàìîì äåëå íå ÿâëÿåòñÿ äåôåêòîì.» (RI CPI FMJD, ïóíêò 2.5.) Íî â äàííîì ñëó÷àå, êàê ó÷àñòíèêè PWCE ìîãóò ïðîòåñòîâàòü, åñëè ó íèõ íåò äàæå ìèíèìàëüíîé èíôîðìàöèè, àáñîëþòíî íèêàêîãî àíàëèçà? È åùå. Òàê êàê âñå çàìå÷àíèÿ ïóáëè÷íî (è äàæå ïåðñîíàëüíî) ÍÅ ÎÁÚßÂËÅÍÛ, ìîãóò ëè áûòü óâåðåíû àâòîðû çàìå÷àíèè, ÷òî âñå èõ çàìå÷àíèÿ äîâåäåíû äî ñóäåé PWCE?
Ïðîâîäÿ êîíêóðñû “Lietuva – 2001” è “Lietuva – 2003”(ïðè ïðîâåäåíèè áîëåå ðàííèõ êîíêóðñîâ åùå íå áûëî øàøå÷íûõ web – site) ÿ âñå ïîëó÷åííûå çàìå÷àíèÿ ïóáëèêîâàë ÅÙÅ ÄÎ îïóáëèêîâàíèÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûõ èòîãîâ. Îò Mr.A.Tavernier óñëûøàë óïðåêè, ÷òî îíè ñëèøêîì ïîäðîáíûå è ò.ï. Îò Mr.S.Yushkevitch óñëûøàë îáâèíåíèÿ, ÷òî íå áûëî çàìå÷àíèè ê äâóì ïîçèöèÿì, êîòîðûì ïî îäíîìó ñóäüè äàëè íóëåâóþ îöåíêó. Êðèòèêó ÿ ïðèíèìàþ, àíàëèçèðóþ, äåëàþ âûâîäû.
 áîëåå ïîçäíèõ êîíêóðñàõ («Ðåòðî» è «Memorial S.de Bruijn”) èõ îðãàíèçàòîðû çàìå÷àíèÿ îáúÿâèëè, îáúÿâëÿÿ ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè. Ñ÷èòàþ, ÷òî ýòî òîæå áîëåå ìåíåå íîðìàëüíî.
Òåïåðü èäåì äàëüøå. Çàìå÷àíèÿ âîîáùå íå îáúÿâëÿþòñÿ. «Ïðåêðàñíî»…Äî îáúÿâëåíèÿ ÎÊÎÍ×ÀÒÅËÜÍÛÕ èòîãîâ íå áóäåò íèêàêèõ ïðîòåñòîâ. Íî êîìó ýòî âûãîäíî?
Best regards,
Algimantas Kaciuska
-
Øêëóäîâ
http://www.shashki.com/index.php?name=P ... ic&p=14968
Ïîñòóïèëî íå ñåêðåòíîå (!) ðåàãèðîâàíèå îò ãîñïîäèíà J.C.R. Bus:
11 Èþí 2006 10:53:53
Mr. Kaciuska,
It is not me, but the contact of the PWCE Mr. Ciron who has the remarks of the PWCE. The function of the contact is among other things to present the end games to the jury without the names of the participants, to collect remarks from different sides and to summarize them.
However, as you know, but you do not say so in your email, there are remarks of a part of the jury that are not according to the RIE.
Mr. Ciron is preparing the publication of the reasons for elimination.
As member of the CPI you should have addressed your email to the CPI only and in this case also to the contact Mr. Ciron.
I will not go into further detail in this case with this distribution list, further remarks to you will be made otherwise.
Regards, J.C.R. Bus
------------------------
(äàëåå êîìïüþòåðíûé ïåðåâîä)
------------------------
Ãîñïîäèí Êà÷þøêà,
Ýòî íå êî ìíå, êîíòàêòèðóéòå ñ PWCE Mr. Ciron, êîòîðûé èìååò çàìå÷àíèÿ PWCE. Ôóíêöèÿ êîíòàêòà äîëæíà, ìåæäó ïðî÷èì, ïðåäñòàâèòü èãðû êîíöà æþðè áåç íàçâàíèé ó÷àñòíèêîâ, ñîáèðàòü çàìå÷àíèÿ îò ðàçëè÷íûõ ñòîðîí è ñóììèðîâàòü èõ.
Îäíàêî, êàê Âû çíàåòå, íî Âû íå ãîâîðèòå òàê â âàøåé ýëåêòðîííîé ïî÷òå, åñòü çàìå÷àíèÿ ÷àñòè æþðè, êîòîðûå íå ñîãëàñíî RIE.
Mr. Ciron ãîòîâèò ïóáëèêàöèþ ïðè÷èí äëÿ óñòðàíåíèÿ.
Êàê ÷ëåí CPI Âû äîëæíû áûëè îáðàòèòüñÿ â âàøåé ýëåêòðîííîé ïî÷òå òîëüêî ê CPI è â ýòîì ñëó÷àå òàêæå ê êîíòàêòó Mr. Ciron.
ß íå áóäó âõîäèòü äàëåå â äåòàëè â ýòîì ñëó÷àå ñ ýòèì ñïèñêîì ðàñïðåäåëåíèÿ, äàëåå çàìå÷àåò ê Âàì, áóäåò ñäåëàí èíà÷å.
Ñ óâàæåíèåì, J.C.R. Bus
-----------------------
ÊÎÌÌÅÍÒÀÐÈÈ
(ìîè ËÈ×ÍÛÅ):
0.
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ ãîñïîäèí J.C.R. Bus ïåðåêëàäûâàåò ñîþ âèíó íà ãîñïîäèíà Ciron... Îêàçûâàåòñÿ íàéäåí êðàéíèé!... Ñòûäíî, J.C.R. Bus!!!
1.
Èç âñåãî ïèñüìà íàèáîëåå öåííà èíôîðìàöèÿ î òîì, ÷òî Mr. Ciron ãîòîâèò çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ïå÷àòè!...
Ïðàâäà ñ ó÷åòîì òîãî, ÷òî ñðîêè ïîäà÷è ïðîòåñòîâ âñ¸ áîëåå è áîëåå óìåíüøàþòñÿ, ìîæíî ñîìíåâàòüñÿ, ÷òî Jacques óñïååò ýòó ðàáîòó ñäåëàòü… À âåäü çàìå÷àíèÿ äîëæíû áûëè áûòü âûñòàâëåíû íà âñåîáùåå îáîçðåíèå åùå â ÿíâàðå, à òî è â äåêàáðå!...
2.
Àëüãèìàíòàñ ïèñàë î òîì, ÷òî äîëæíû áûòü èçâåñòíû ôàìèëèè òåõ, êòî ïîäàë çàìå÷àíèÿ! J.C.R. Bus ïèøåò, ÷òî ÿêîáû ðå÷ü øëà î ôàìèëèÿõ ó÷àñòíèêîâ PWCE?!... Âîò îíè ïðåëåñòè êîìïüþòåðíîãî ïåðåâîäà…
3.
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ J.C.R. Bus ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî, óêàçàííûõ ìíîé ïóíêòîâ RIE, íåäîñòàòî÷íî äëÿ òîãî, ÷òîáû äàòü íóëåâûå îöåíêè òðåì ïîçèöèÿì. Ïî åãî ñëîâàì ïîëó÷àåòñÿ, ÷òî ïðàâèëà RIE, ìíîé óêàçàííûå íå, íå ÿâëÿþòñÿ ïðàâèëàìè RIE… Ïî÷åìó ñâîå ëè÷íîå ìíåíèå îí ñòàâèò âûøå RIE?
4.
Íî îí óìàë÷èâàåò î ãëàâíîì: ïî÷åìó, âûñòàâëåííûå-òàêè ïîä ÅÃÎ äàâëåíèåì, ìíîé îöåíêè íå áûëè ó÷òåíû??? Èëè îïÿòü J.C.R. Bus ïðîñòî ýòîãî íå õîòåë ëè÷íî?...
5.
J.C.R. Bus ïðèçûâàåò Àëüãèìàíòàñà, áåçäåÿòåëüíîñòü J.C.R. Bus, èëè äåÿòåëüíîñòü J.C.R. Bus, íå ñïîñîáñòâóþùóþ ðàçâèòèþ øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè ÕÐÀÍÈÒÜ â ñåêðåòå! (?), ïîëüçóÿñü òîëüêî «âíóòðåííåé» ïåðåïèñêîé â CPI. È äàæå óãðîæàåò (èëè ýòî îïÿòü ïðåëåñòè êîìïüþòåðíîãî ïåðåâîäà?): «äàëåå çàìå÷àåò ê Âàì, áóäåò ñäåëàí èíà÷å».
À ýòî î÷åíü èíòåðåñíî!!!
Äàâàéòå íå áóäåì êðèòèêîâàòü íåäîñòàòêè!
Äàâàéòå áóäåì ñ íèìè æèòü…
6.
 ñâÿçè ñ ýòèì, ìíå ñòàíîâèòñÿ ÿñíûì íåæåëàíèå J.C.R. Bus âèäåòü â CPI êîãî-ëèáî, êòî îñìåëèëñÿ åãî êðèòèêîâàòü… Êàæåòñÿ, ïîðà çàäóìàòüñÿ î ñîîòâåòñòâèè J.C.R. Bus çàíèìàåìîé èì äîëæíîñòè… Åãî îòñòàâêà áóäåò ëó÷øèì âûõîäîì èç ñëîæèâøåéñÿ ñèòóàöèè, ïðîïèòàííîé àâòîðèòàðèçìîì J.C.R. Bus.
Ïîñòóïèëî íå ñåêðåòíîå (!) ðåàãèðîâàíèå îò ãîñïîäèíà J.C.R. Bus:
11 Èþí 2006 10:53:53
Mr. Kaciuska,
It is not me, but the contact of the PWCE Mr. Ciron who has the remarks of the PWCE. The function of the contact is among other things to present the end games to the jury without the names of the participants, to collect remarks from different sides and to summarize them.
However, as you know, but you do not say so in your email, there are remarks of a part of the jury that are not according to the RIE.
Mr. Ciron is preparing the publication of the reasons for elimination.
As member of the CPI you should have addressed your email to the CPI only and in this case also to the contact Mr. Ciron.
I will not go into further detail in this case with this distribution list, further remarks to you will be made otherwise.
Regards, J.C.R. Bus
------------------------
(äàëåå êîìïüþòåðíûé ïåðåâîä)
------------------------
Ãîñïîäèí Êà÷þøêà,
Ýòî íå êî ìíå, êîíòàêòèðóéòå ñ PWCE Mr. Ciron, êîòîðûé èìååò çàìå÷àíèÿ PWCE. Ôóíêöèÿ êîíòàêòà äîëæíà, ìåæäó ïðî÷èì, ïðåäñòàâèòü èãðû êîíöà æþðè áåç íàçâàíèé ó÷àñòíèêîâ, ñîáèðàòü çàìå÷àíèÿ îò ðàçëè÷íûõ ñòîðîí è ñóììèðîâàòü èõ.
Îäíàêî, êàê Âû çíàåòå, íî Âû íå ãîâîðèòå òàê â âàøåé ýëåêòðîííîé ïî÷òå, åñòü çàìå÷àíèÿ ÷àñòè æþðè, êîòîðûå íå ñîãëàñíî RIE.
Mr. Ciron ãîòîâèò ïóáëèêàöèþ ïðè÷èí äëÿ óñòðàíåíèÿ.
Êàê ÷ëåí CPI Âû äîëæíû áûëè îáðàòèòüñÿ â âàøåé ýëåêòðîííîé ïî÷òå òîëüêî ê CPI è â ýòîì ñëó÷àå òàêæå ê êîíòàêòó Mr. Ciron.
ß íå áóäó âõîäèòü äàëåå â äåòàëè â ýòîì ñëó÷àå ñ ýòèì ñïèñêîì ðàñïðåäåëåíèÿ, äàëåå çàìå÷àåò ê Âàì, áóäåò ñäåëàí èíà÷å.
Ñ óâàæåíèåì, J.C.R. Bus
-----------------------
ÊÎÌÌÅÍÒÀÐÈÈ
(ìîè ËÈ×ÍÛÅ):
0.
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ ãîñïîäèí J.C.R. Bus ïåðåêëàäûâàåò ñîþ âèíó íà ãîñïîäèíà Ciron... Îêàçûâàåòñÿ íàéäåí êðàéíèé!... Ñòûäíî, J.C.R. Bus!!!
1.
Èç âñåãî ïèñüìà íàèáîëåå öåííà èíôîðìàöèÿ î òîì, ÷òî Mr. Ciron ãîòîâèò çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ïå÷àòè!...
Ïðàâäà ñ ó÷åòîì òîãî, ÷òî ñðîêè ïîäà÷è ïðîòåñòîâ âñ¸ áîëåå è áîëåå óìåíüøàþòñÿ, ìîæíî ñîìíåâàòüñÿ, ÷òî Jacques óñïååò ýòó ðàáîòó ñäåëàòü… À âåäü çàìå÷àíèÿ äîëæíû áûëè áûòü âûñòàâëåíû íà âñåîáùåå îáîçðåíèå åùå â ÿíâàðå, à òî è â äåêàáðå!...
2.
Àëüãèìàíòàñ ïèñàë î òîì, ÷òî äîëæíû áûòü èçâåñòíû ôàìèëèè òåõ, êòî ïîäàë çàìå÷àíèÿ! J.C.R. Bus ïèøåò, ÷òî ÿêîáû ðå÷ü øëà î ôàìèëèÿõ ó÷àñòíèêîâ PWCE?!... Âîò îíè ïðåëåñòè êîìïüþòåðíîãî ïåðåâîäà…
3.
Îêàçûâàåòñÿ J.C.R. Bus ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî, óêàçàííûõ ìíîé ïóíêòîâ RIE, íåäîñòàòî÷íî äëÿ òîãî, ÷òîáû äàòü íóëåâûå îöåíêè òðåì ïîçèöèÿì. Ïî åãî ñëîâàì ïîëó÷àåòñÿ, ÷òî ïðàâèëà RIE, ìíîé óêàçàííûå íå, íå ÿâëÿþòñÿ ïðàâèëàìè RIE… Ïî÷åìó ñâîå ëè÷íîå ìíåíèå îí ñòàâèò âûøå RIE?
4.
Íî îí óìàë÷èâàåò î ãëàâíîì: ïî÷åìó, âûñòàâëåííûå-òàêè ïîä ÅÃÎ äàâëåíèåì, ìíîé îöåíêè íå áûëè ó÷òåíû??? Èëè îïÿòü J.C.R. Bus ïðîñòî ýòîãî íå õîòåë ëè÷íî?...
5.
J.C.R. Bus ïðèçûâàåò Àëüãèìàíòàñà, áåçäåÿòåëüíîñòü J.C.R. Bus, èëè äåÿòåëüíîñòü J.C.R. Bus, íå ñïîñîáñòâóþùóþ ðàçâèòèþ øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè ÕÐÀÍÈÒÜ â ñåêðåòå! (?), ïîëüçóÿñü òîëüêî «âíóòðåííåé» ïåðåïèñêîé â CPI. È äàæå óãðîæàåò (èëè ýòî îïÿòü ïðåëåñòè êîìïüþòåðíîãî ïåðåâîäà?): «äàëåå çàìå÷àåò ê Âàì, áóäåò ñäåëàí èíà÷å».
À ýòî î÷åíü èíòåðåñíî!!!
Äàâàéòå íå áóäåì êðèòèêîâàòü íåäîñòàòêè!
Äàâàéòå áóäåì ñ íèìè æèòü…
6.
 ñâÿçè ñ ýòèì, ìíå ñòàíîâèòñÿ ÿñíûì íåæåëàíèå J.C.R. Bus âèäåòü â CPI êîãî-ëèáî, êòî îñìåëèëñÿ åãî êðèòèêîâàòü… Êàæåòñÿ, ïîðà çàäóìàòüñÿ î ñîîòâåòñòâèè J.C.R. Bus çàíèìàåìîé èì äîëæíîñòè… Åãî îòñòàâêà áóäåò ëó÷øèì âûõîäîì èç ñëîæèâøåéñÿ ñèòóàöèè, ïðîïèòàííîé àâòîðèòàðèçìîì J.C.R. Bus.
-
Guest
Îòâåò Àëüãèìàíòàñà Êà÷þøêè
11 Èþí 2006 14:14:12
http://www.shashki.com/index.php?name=P ... ic&p=14972
Mr. J.Bus,
Preliminary results PWCE are declared 01 – 06 – 2006. Participants to make protests from – for rejected (the received 0 glasses) positions (such – about 50 percents) have time only up to 01 – 07 - 2006. Remarks to positions today, 11 – 06 – 2006, are not declared also to participants not known. Participants (for example, I can tell one surname – Mr. A.Fedoruk) – address to members ÑPI with the request urgently to explain a situation. It I write because you even pretend, that do not understand about what there is a speech.
And after that you accuse me that I have lifted (has announced) this problem, instead of has written about it only to you. On bureaucratic procedures already there is no time. It is assured, if has written only to you, you would answer, that you do not have time and that it not so it is important. So was more than once.
You have made a gross blunder, that 01 – 06 – 2006 have declared preliminary results PWCE without the announcement the remark to positions. Also have declared preliminary results with rough distortion of true estimations of judges PWCE (references judges PWCE Mr. R.Mackevicius, Mr. P.Shkludov).
With impatience I shall wait the remark, punishment from you or other heads FMJD. And explanatories – for what.
Regards, Algimantas Kaciuska
Mr.J.Bus,
Ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE îáúÿâëåíû 01 – 06 – 2006. Ó÷àñòíèêè ñäåëàòü ïðîòåñòû èç – çà áðàêîâàííûõ (ïîëó÷èâøèõ 0 î÷êîâ) ïîçèöèè (òàêèõ – îêîëî 50 ïðîö.) èìåþò âðåìåíè òîëüêî äî 01 – 07 - 2006. Çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ïîçèöèÿì ñåãîäíÿ,11 – 06 – 2006, íå îáúÿâëåíû è ó÷àñòíèêàì íå èçâåñòíûå. Ó÷àñòíèêè (íàïðèìåð, ìîãó ñêàçàòü îäíó ôàìèëèþ – Mr .A .Fedoruk ) – îáðàùàþòñÿ ê ÷ëåíàì ÑPI ñ ïðîñüáîé ñðî÷íî ðàçúÿñíèòü ñèòóàöèþ. Ýòî ïèøó ïîòîìó, ÷òî Âû äàæå äåëàåòå âèä, ÷òî íå ïîíèìàåòå î ÷åì èäåò ðå÷ü.
È ïîñëå ýòîãî Âû ìåíÿ îáâèíÿåòå â òîì, ÷òî ÿ ïîäíÿë (îãëàñèë) ýòó ïðîáëåìó, à íå íàïèñàë îá ýòîì òîëüêî Âàì. Íà áþðîêðàòè÷åñêèå ïðîöåäóðû óæå íåò âðåìåíè. Óâåðåí, åñëè áû íàïèñàë òîëüêî Âàì, Âû áû îòâåòèëè, ÷òî ó Âàñ íåò âðåìåíè è ÷òî ýòî íå òàê âàæíî. Òàê áûëî óæå íå ðàç.
Âû ñäåëàëè ãðóáóþ îøèáêó, ÷òî 01 – 06 – 2006 îáúÿâèëè ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE áåç îáúÿâëåíèÿ çàìå÷àíèè ê ïîçèöèÿì. È îáúÿâèëè ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå ðåçóëüòàòû ñ ãðóáûì èñêàæåíèåì èñòèííûõ îöåíîê ñóäåé PWCE (ñì.çàÿâëåíèå ñóäåé PWCE Mr .R .Mackevicius , Mr .P .Shkludov ).
Ñ íåòåðïåíèåì áóäó æäàòü çàìå÷àíèè, íàêàçàíèè ñ Âàñ èëè äðóãèõ ðóêîâîäèòåëåé FMJD . È ïîÿñíåíèÿ – çà ÷òî.
Regards, Algimantas Kaciuska
11 Èþí 2006 14:14:12
http://www.shashki.com/index.php?name=P ... ic&p=14972
Mr. J.Bus,
Preliminary results PWCE are declared 01 – 06 – 2006. Participants to make protests from – for rejected (the received 0 glasses) positions (such – about 50 percents) have time only up to 01 – 07 - 2006. Remarks to positions today, 11 – 06 – 2006, are not declared also to participants not known. Participants (for example, I can tell one surname – Mr. A.Fedoruk) – address to members ÑPI with the request urgently to explain a situation. It I write because you even pretend, that do not understand about what there is a speech.
And after that you accuse me that I have lifted (has announced) this problem, instead of has written about it only to you. On bureaucratic procedures already there is no time. It is assured, if has written only to you, you would answer, that you do not have time and that it not so it is important. So was more than once.
You have made a gross blunder, that 01 – 06 – 2006 have declared preliminary results PWCE without the announcement the remark to positions. Also have declared preliminary results with rough distortion of true estimations of judges PWCE (references judges PWCE Mr. R.Mackevicius, Mr. P.Shkludov).
With impatience I shall wait the remark, punishment from you or other heads FMJD. And explanatories – for what.
Regards, Algimantas Kaciuska
Mr.J.Bus,
Ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE îáúÿâëåíû 01 – 06 – 2006. Ó÷àñòíèêè ñäåëàòü ïðîòåñòû èç – çà áðàêîâàííûõ (ïîëó÷èâøèõ 0 î÷êîâ) ïîçèöèè (òàêèõ – îêîëî 50 ïðîö.) èìåþò âðåìåíè òîëüêî äî 01 – 07 - 2006. Çàìå÷àíèÿ ê ïîçèöèÿì ñåãîäíÿ,11 – 06 – 2006, íå îáúÿâëåíû è ó÷àñòíèêàì íå èçâåñòíûå. Ó÷àñòíèêè (íàïðèìåð, ìîãó ñêàçàòü îäíó ôàìèëèþ – Mr .A .Fedoruk ) – îáðàùàþòñÿ ê ÷ëåíàì ÑPI ñ ïðîñüáîé ñðî÷íî ðàçúÿñíèòü ñèòóàöèþ. Ýòî ïèøó ïîòîìó, ÷òî Âû äàæå äåëàåòå âèä, ÷òî íå ïîíèìàåòå î ÷åì èäåò ðå÷ü.
È ïîñëå ýòîãî Âû ìåíÿ îáâèíÿåòå â òîì, ÷òî ÿ ïîäíÿë (îãëàñèë) ýòó ïðîáëåìó, à íå íàïèñàë îá ýòîì òîëüêî Âàì. Íà áþðîêðàòè÷åñêèå ïðîöåäóðû óæå íåò âðåìåíè. Óâåðåí, åñëè áû íàïèñàë òîëüêî Âàì, Âû áû îòâåòèëè, ÷òî ó Âàñ íåò âðåìåíè è ÷òî ýòî íå òàê âàæíî. Òàê áûëî óæå íå ðàç.
Âû ñäåëàëè ãðóáóþ îøèáêó, ÷òî 01 – 06 – 2006 îáúÿâèëè ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå èòîãè PWCE áåç îáúÿâëåíèÿ çàìå÷àíèè ê ïîçèöèÿì. È îáúÿâèëè ïðåäâàðèòåëüíûå ðåçóëüòàòû ñ ãðóáûì èñêàæåíèåì èñòèííûõ îöåíîê ñóäåé PWCE (ñì.çàÿâëåíèå ñóäåé PWCE Mr .R .Mackevicius , Mr .P .Shkludov ).
Ñ íåòåðïåíèåì áóäó æäàòü çàìå÷àíèè, íàêàçàíèè ñ Âàñ èëè äðóãèõ ðóêîâîäèòåëåé FMJD . È ïîÿñíåíèÿ – çà ÷òî.
Regards, Algimantas Kaciuska
-
Shkludov
Êàêîå-òî ñòðàííîå çàòèøüå…
Êàê ïåðåä áîåì!...
Ñèæó, îáäóìûâàþ ðàññòàíîâêó ñèë è âîçìîæíûå ðåçóëüòàòû.
Òî, ÷òî «ìóðàâåéíèê» îáëèëè êèïÿòêîì – ýòî ôàêò, à ÷òî æå äàëüøå?
À ïî÷åìó??? Ïî÷åìó âîîáùå òàêîå ìîãëî ñëó÷èòüñÿ?
Àìáèöèîçíîñòü èãðàåò íåìàëóþ ðîëü… Íî íå ãëàâíóþ! Çíà÷èò, áûëè ñîçäàíû õîðîøèå óñëîâèÿ äëÿ êîíôëèêòà!...
Íà÷íåì ÷òî ëè ñ Ïðàâèë. Ïðàâèëà CPI FMJD èçíà÷àëüíî ñîçäàâàëèñü â ñèòóàöèè áëèçêîé ê áîåâîé. Ïðàâèëà íàäî áûëî ïèñàòü ÁÛÑÒÐÎ, òàê êàê ëþäè õîòåëè íàêîíåö-òî íà÷àòü ÑÎÐÅÂÍÎÂÀÍÈß!
Ïðàâèëà íå ïèñàëèñü èñõîäÿ èç ËÎÃÈÊÈ è ïîòðåáíîñòåé ØÀØÅ×ÍÎÉ ÊÎÌÏÎÇÈÖÈÈ! Ïðàâèëà ïèñàëèñü èñõîäÿ èç ïîòðåáíîñòåé ËÞÄÅÉ, çà÷àñòóþ çàèíòåðåñîâàííûõ â ëîááèðîâàíèè ñâîèõ, îòíþäü íå ïåðåäîâûõ, èäåé è çàìûñëîâ! Þøêåâè÷ èñêàë ÊÎÍÑÅÍÑÓÑ ìåæäó Âîñòîêîì è Çàïàäîì. Ïðè÷åì óêëîí áûë çàðàíåå çàäàí â ñòîðîíó Çàïàäà… Íå îáèäåòü áû ñîïëÿêàì ïàòðèàðõîâ è çà÷èíàòåëåé. (ßñíî, ÷òî â Ñîþçå íà÷àëè çàíèìàòüñÿ ñîòêàìè ïîçæå… Íî ÿñíî è òî, ÷òî, íå çàâèñèìî îò ýòîãî, ÂÎ ÂÑÅÌ îáîãíàëè ó÷èòåëåé!).
Ïðàâèëà Ýòþäîâ òàê æå ÈÇÍÀ×ÀËÜÍÎ ïèñàëèñü «ñî ñâÿçàííûìè ðóêàìè»!... Âèäèìî Àëüãèìàíòàñ Êà÷þøêà ïîëó÷èë ðàñïîðÿæåíèå íå âäàâàòüñÿ â íîâàòîðñòâî… À ïîòîìó ìíå íå áûëî ïîçâîëåíî äîâåñòè òåêñò Ïðàâèë äî áîëåå-ìåíåå ïðèåìëåìîãî âèäà. Ïîòîìó, âèäÿ ýòî, ÿ îòêàçàëñÿ îò ñîó÷àñòèÿ â ðàáîòå íàä ýòèìè Ïðàâèëàìè. Îêîí÷àòåëüíûé æå âàðèàíò, óòâåðæäåííûé CPI FMJD, ïî-âèäèìîìó óäèâèë è êóðàòîðà ðàáîò À. Êà÷þøêó!... Þøêåâè÷, è â áîëüøåé ÷àñòè Bus ïîñòàðàëèñü èñïîðòèòü â ïðèíöèïå íå ïëîõîé (õîòÿ è ñëàáîâàòûé) òåêñò äî òàêîé ñòåïåíè, ÷òî ñìûñë â íåì ïîðîþ ïðîñòî íå ïðîñìàòðèâàëñÿ.
----
Âïåðâûå ïðîìåëüêíóëà ôàìèëèÿ Bus!
----
Íàäî ñêàçàòü, ÷òî ìíå, êàê ñóäüå PWCE ïðèøëîñü íåìàëî ïîòðóäèòüñÿ, ÷òîáû ñâåñòè õîòÿ áû êàêèå-òî, êîíöû ñ êîíöàìè â ýòîì òåêñòå Ïðàâèë Ýòþäîâ. È, óâû, ïåðâàÿ æå îáêàòêà Ïðàâèë âûÿâèëà ïîðÿäêà ïÿòè «äûðîê» â Ïðàâèëàõ.  îñíîâíîì ýòî ÍÅÄÎÃÎÂÎÐÊÈ.  Ïðàâèëàõ ìíîãî âíèìàíèÿ çàîñòðÿåòñÿ ïîðîþ íà ñóùåé ÷åïóõå, à âàæíûå ÒÅÕÍÈ×ÅÑÊÈÅ âîïðîñû ðàññìàòðèâàþòñÿ âòîðîïÿõ, íåïîëíî, îáðûâî÷íî… Óâû, è àõ!...
Òàêèì îáðàçîì ìû âûÿñíèëè, ÷òî ïî÷âà äëÿ êîíôëèêòà áûëà… È ê ñîçäàíèþ ïðåäêîíôëèêòíîé ñèòóàöèè ïðè÷àñòåí… Bus.
Íà÷àëñÿ PWCE.
Ðàáîòà çàòÿíóëà â îìóò…
Óâû, åñòü è ìîÿ âèíà… Çà ýòîé ðàáîòîé ÿ äàæå íå ïîäóìàë î òîì, ÷òî ÍÀÄÎ îçíàêîìèòü ñ îáíàðóæåííûì áðàêîì è ó÷àñòíèêîâ!!! È íå ïðåäóïðåäèë îá ýòîì êîîðäèíàòîðà PWCE ãîñïîäèíà Ceron…
 èòîãå ñóäåéñêîé ðàáîòû êàê ðàç è îáíàðóæèëèñü ðàñõîæäåíèÿ â ïîíèìàíèè øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè Çàïàäíîé è Âîñòî÷íîé øêîë.
×òî ñäåëàëà CPI?
Bus ñòàë íàñòàèâàòü (äàâèòü íà ñóäåé), ÷òî áû îíè ïðèøëè ê åäèíîìó ìíåíèþ. Îí ÿâíî íå ïîíèìàë, ÷òî çäåñü ñòîëêíóëèñü ôèëîñîôèè ðàçíûõ øêîë øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè… È ÷òî â îäíî÷àñüå íèêòî íå èçìåíèò ñâîèõ ìèðîâîççðåíèé!
Âîò çäåñü ÿ óæå çàîñòðÿë âíèìàíèå ãîñïîäèíà Ceron íà òîì, ÊÀÊÈÅ âîïðîñû íàäî ïîäàòü íà ðàññìîòðåíèå CPI â Âàðøàâå. Óâû, ðàññìîòðåí áûë òîëüêî âîïðîñ ïóáëèêàöèè â ôîðóìå!... À âñå îñòàëüíûå âîïðîñû ãîñïîäèí Ceron ïîñòàâèë ïåðåä CPI ñ îïîçäàíèåì è â òàêîì âèäå, ÷òî ÷ëåíû CPI ìîãëè âîîáùå íå ïîíÿòü ÑÓÒÈ ïðîáëåìû. Êà÷þøêà îòâåòèë ïðàêòè÷åñêè ñðàçó, Ìàòóñ ÷óòü ïîçæå è íå î÷åíü êîíêðåòíî. Êîíêðåòíîãî îòâåòà Bus æäàòü íå ñòàë, çàÿâèâ, ÷òî Ìàòóñ ÍÅ ÎÒÂÅÒÈË… Íå îòâåòèë?... Èëè Busu õîòåëîñü ñäåëàòü âèä, ÷òî íå îòâåòèë?
----
Îïÿòü Bus…
----
Çäåñü ñëåäóåò ðàñêðûòü îäèí ñåêðåò: Bus íåìíîãî ïðè÷àñòåí è ê ýòþäíîìó òâîð÷åñòâó, íî… ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî æàíð ýòþäîâ çíàåò ÒÎËÜÊÎ îí!... Óâû, ýòî íå òàê.
Äàëåå ïîñëåäîâàëî ïðàêòè÷åñêè åäèíîëè÷íîå ðåøåíèå Busa ïî PWCE.
Ñóäüè ïîäàëè ïðîòåñò.
Ïðîòåñò ïî òàêîé àâòîðèòàðíîé ðàáîòå ïîäàë è À. Êà÷þøêà.
Çíàÿ, ÷òî ïèñàòü ëè÷íî Bus áåñïîëåçíî (ìîæíî óòîíóòü â áþðîêðàòèè!) À. Êà÷þøêà íàïèñàë ïðîòåñò â FMJD, è âñåì ñîñòàâèòåëÿì, êîòîðûå ìîãóò áûòü çàèíòåðåñîâàíû â ýòîì. (Íó, â êîíöå êîíöîâ, íå ïèøåò çàÿö ïðîòåñò íà ïîâåäåíèå âîëêà, âîëêó!... Ïèøåò ÌÅÄÂÅÄÞ!)
È âîò ìû æäåì…
À ÷òî æå ìîæåò ñëó÷èòüñÿ?...
 DC FMJD ñåé÷àñ Ïòèöèí, Õèëüäåðèíã è Bus…
----
Îïÿòü Bus…
----
ßñíî, ÷òî Bus ÍÅ ÈÌÅÅÒ ÏÐÀÂÀ ãîëîñà ïî âîïðîñàì êàñàþùèìñÿ åãî ñàìîãî! Îí çàèíòåðåñîâàííîå ëèöî! Õèëüäåðèíã? Ýòî íå ñåêðåò: ó Õèëüäåðèíãà ñ Busom îáùèå äåëà è äðóæáà!... Êîíå÷íî æå Õèëüäåðèíã áðîñèòñÿ âñåìè äîçâîëåííûìè è íåäîçâîëåííûìè ñïîñîáàìè çàùèùàòü ÄÐÓÃÀ îò ýòèõ äèêàðåé ñ Âîñòîêà… È ìîæåò ñëó÷èòüñÿ, ÷òî îí íà÷íåò èãðó íå ïðàâèëàì. Íàïðèìåð ïîñòàâèò âîïðîñ: èëè/èëè! Èëè, äîïóñòèì, èç CPI óõîäèò À. Êà÷þøêà (à ïî÷åìó áû è íåò? Bus äàâíî óãðîæàåò Êà÷þøêå ñàíêöèÿìè!), èëè (÷òî áû òàêîå ñòðàøíîå ïðèäóìàòü?), íàïðèìåð, CPI èñêëþ÷àò èç FMJD! À ÷òî? Ýòî óãðîçà!
 äàííîé ñèòóàöèè î÷åíü âàæíà ðåàêöèÿ Ïòèöèíà, Ìàòóñà, Çóáîâà, âïðî÷åì, êàê è âñåãî ñîîáùåñòâà øàøå÷íûõ êîìïîçèòîðîâ, íî â ïåðâóþ î÷åðåäü ÈÕ!
Ìîå ëè÷íîå ìíåíèå?
CPI ñ Busom ìíå íå íóæíà…
Óæå ñåé÷àñ ÿ ÷óâñòâóþ, ÷òî ðàáîòàòü ñ íèì áóäåò ÏÐÎÑÒÎ ÍÅÂÎÇÌÎÆÍÎ!
CPI áåç FMJD?
Õì… À ìîæåò áûòü ýòî âûõîä?!
Ñåé÷àñ CPI (ñ Busom) òîðìîçèò òàêèå âîïðîñû êàê: 1) îðãàíèçàöèÿ CPI-64, 2) ðàñøèðåíèå CPI çà ñ÷åò Áåëàðóñè è Óêðàèíû, 3) ðàáîòà íàä Ïðàâèëàìè çàäà÷ è Ïðàâèëàìè äëÿ CPI-64. CPI äàæå íå âûïîëíÿåò ïðèíÿòûõ â Âàðøàâå ðåøåíèé…
----
È çäåñü òîðìîçèò Bus…
----
Ãîñïîäà, íî åñëè íà äîðîãå ëåæèò ÊÀÌÅÍÜ, åãî íàäî óáðàòü, à íå ÷åðòûõàòüñÿ êàæäóþ ìèíóòó!
Ìîæåò áûòü è äðóãîé âûõîä: ñäåëàòü îáúåçä! Íî ýòî, ñêîðåå âñåãî, èìåííî è áóäåò âûõîä CPI èç FMJD. Íåóæåëè FMJD ïàíàöåÿ? Íåóæåëè ìû íå ìîæåì ñîçäàòü Àññîöèàöèþ Øàøå÷íûõ Êîìïîçèòîðîâ, êîòîðàÿ ìîãëà áû áûòü ÇÀÐÅÃÈÑÒÐÈÐÎÂÀÍÀ þðèäè÷åñêè, è ïðîâîäèëà áû ×åìïèîíàòû Ìèðà âíå FMJD???
Ó áîêñåðîâ, äà è ó øàõìàòèñòîâ íå îäíî îáúåäèíåíèå ñ ïðàâîì ïðîâåäåíèÿ ×åìïèîíàòîâ Ìèðà ïî âåðñèè ***!
Ñåé÷àñ âèäèìî, íàäî ñìåíèòü âîïðîñ: «Êòî âèíîâàò?», íà âîïðîñ «×òî äåëàòü?»…
È ïîñòåïåííî íà÷àòü ÄÅËÀÒÜ Àññîöèàöèþ ÑÂÎÁÎÄÍÓÞ îò áþðîêðàòèçìà è äèêòàòà FMJD!
Êàê ïåðåä áîåì!...
Ñèæó, îáäóìûâàþ ðàññòàíîâêó ñèë è âîçìîæíûå ðåçóëüòàòû.
Òî, ÷òî «ìóðàâåéíèê» îáëèëè êèïÿòêîì – ýòî ôàêò, à ÷òî æå äàëüøå?
À ïî÷åìó??? Ïî÷åìó âîîáùå òàêîå ìîãëî ñëó÷èòüñÿ?
Àìáèöèîçíîñòü èãðàåò íåìàëóþ ðîëü… Íî íå ãëàâíóþ! Çíà÷èò, áûëè ñîçäàíû õîðîøèå óñëîâèÿ äëÿ êîíôëèêòà!...
Íà÷íåì ÷òî ëè ñ Ïðàâèë. Ïðàâèëà CPI FMJD èçíà÷àëüíî ñîçäàâàëèñü â ñèòóàöèè áëèçêîé ê áîåâîé. Ïðàâèëà íàäî áûëî ïèñàòü ÁÛÑÒÐÎ, òàê êàê ëþäè õîòåëè íàêîíåö-òî íà÷àòü ÑÎÐÅÂÍÎÂÀÍÈß!
Ïðàâèëà íå ïèñàëèñü èñõîäÿ èç ËÎÃÈÊÈ è ïîòðåáíîñòåé ØÀØÅ×ÍÎÉ ÊÎÌÏÎÇÈÖÈÈ! Ïðàâèëà ïèñàëèñü èñõîäÿ èç ïîòðåáíîñòåé ËÞÄÅÉ, çà÷àñòóþ çàèíòåðåñîâàííûõ â ëîááèðîâàíèè ñâîèõ, îòíþäü íå ïåðåäîâûõ, èäåé è çàìûñëîâ! Þøêåâè÷ èñêàë ÊÎÍÑÅÍÑÓÑ ìåæäó Âîñòîêîì è Çàïàäîì. Ïðè÷åì óêëîí áûë çàðàíåå çàäàí â ñòîðîíó Çàïàäà… Íå îáèäåòü áû ñîïëÿêàì ïàòðèàðõîâ è çà÷èíàòåëåé. (ßñíî, ÷òî â Ñîþçå íà÷àëè çàíèìàòüñÿ ñîòêàìè ïîçæå… Íî ÿñíî è òî, ÷òî, íå çàâèñèìî îò ýòîãî, ÂÎ ÂÑÅÌ îáîãíàëè ó÷èòåëåé!).
Ïðàâèëà Ýòþäîâ òàê æå ÈÇÍÀ×ÀËÜÍÎ ïèñàëèñü «ñî ñâÿçàííûìè ðóêàìè»!... Âèäèìî Àëüãèìàíòàñ Êà÷þøêà ïîëó÷èë ðàñïîðÿæåíèå íå âäàâàòüñÿ â íîâàòîðñòâî… À ïîòîìó ìíå íå áûëî ïîçâîëåíî äîâåñòè òåêñò Ïðàâèë äî áîëåå-ìåíåå ïðèåìëåìîãî âèäà. Ïîòîìó, âèäÿ ýòî, ÿ îòêàçàëñÿ îò ñîó÷àñòèÿ â ðàáîòå íàä ýòèìè Ïðàâèëàìè. Îêîí÷àòåëüíûé æå âàðèàíò, óòâåðæäåííûé CPI FMJD, ïî-âèäèìîìó óäèâèë è êóðàòîðà ðàáîò À. Êà÷þøêó!... Þøêåâè÷, è â áîëüøåé ÷àñòè Bus ïîñòàðàëèñü èñïîðòèòü â ïðèíöèïå íå ïëîõîé (õîòÿ è ñëàáîâàòûé) òåêñò äî òàêîé ñòåïåíè, ÷òî ñìûñë â íåì ïîðîþ ïðîñòî íå ïðîñìàòðèâàëñÿ.
----
Âïåðâûå ïðîìåëüêíóëà ôàìèëèÿ Bus!
----
Íàäî ñêàçàòü, ÷òî ìíå, êàê ñóäüå PWCE ïðèøëîñü íåìàëî ïîòðóäèòüñÿ, ÷òîáû ñâåñòè õîòÿ áû êàêèå-òî, êîíöû ñ êîíöàìè â ýòîì òåêñòå Ïðàâèë Ýòþäîâ. È, óâû, ïåðâàÿ æå îáêàòêà Ïðàâèë âûÿâèëà ïîðÿäêà ïÿòè «äûðîê» â Ïðàâèëàõ.  îñíîâíîì ýòî ÍÅÄÎÃÎÂÎÐÊÈ.  Ïðàâèëàõ ìíîãî âíèìàíèÿ çàîñòðÿåòñÿ ïîðîþ íà ñóùåé ÷åïóõå, à âàæíûå ÒÅÕÍÈ×ÅÑÊÈÅ âîïðîñû ðàññìàòðèâàþòñÿ âòîðîïÿõ, íåïîëíî, îáðûâî÷íî… Óâû, è àõ!...
Òàêèì îáðàçîì ìû âûÿñíèëè, ÷òî ïî÷âà äëÿ êîíôëèêòà áûëà… È ê ñîçäàíèþ ïðåäêîíôëèêòíîé ñèòóàöèè ïðè÷àñòåí… Bus.
Íà÷àëñÿ PWCE.
Ðàáîòà çàòÿíóëà â îìóò…
Óâû, åñòü è ìîÿ âèíà… Çà ýòîé ðàáîòîé ÿ äàæå íå ïîäóìàë î òîì, ÷òî ÍÀÄÎ îçíàêîìèòü ñ îáíàðóæåííûì áðàêîì è ó÷àñòíèêîâ!!! È íå ïðåäóïðåäèë îá ýòîì êîîðäèíàòîðà PWCE ãîñïîäèíà Ceron…
 èòîãå ñóäåéñêîé ðàáîòû êàê ðàç è îáíàðóæèëèñü ðàñõîæäåíèÿ â ïîíèìàíèè øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè Çàïàäíîé è Âîñòî÷íîé øêîë.
×òî ñäåëàëà CPI?
Bus ñòàë íàñòàèâàòü (äàâèòü íà ñóäåé), ÷òî áû îíè ïðèøëè ê åäèíîìó ìíåíèþ. Îí ÿâíî íå ïîíèìàë, ÷òî çäåñü ñòîëêíóëèñü ôèëîñîôèè ðàçíûõ øêîë øàøå÷íîé êîìïîçèöèè… È ÷òî â îäíî÷àñüå íèêòî íå èçìåíèò ñâîèõ ìèðîâîççðåíèé!
Âîò çäåñü ÿ óæå çàîñòðÿë âíèìàíèå ãîñïîäèíà Ceron íà òîì, ÊÀÊÈÅ âîïðîñû íàäî ïîäàòü íà ðàññìîòðåíèå CPI â Âàðøàâå. Óâû, ðàññìîòðåí áûë òîëüêî âîïðîñ ïóáëèêàöèè â ôîðóìå!... À âñå îñòàëüíûå âîïðîñû ãîñïîäèí Ceron ïîñòàâèë ïåðåä CPI ñ îïîçäàíèåì è â òàêîì âèäå, ÷òî ÷ëåíû CPI ìîãëè âîîáùå íå ïîíÿòü ÑÓÒÈ ïðîáëåìû. Êà÷þøêà îòâåòèë ïðàêòè÷åñêè ñðàçó, Ìàòóñ ÷óòü ïîçæå è íå î÷åíü êîíêðåòíî. Êîíêðåòíîãî îòâåòà Bus æäàòü íå ñòàë, çàÿâèâ, ÷òî Ìàòóñ ÍÅ ÎÒÂÅÒÈË… Íå îòâåòèë?... Èëè Busu õîòåëîñü ñäåëàòü âèä, ÷òî íå îòâåòèë?
----
Îïÿòü Bus…
----
Çäåñü ñëåäóåò ðàñêðûòü îäèí ñåêðåò: Bus íåìíîãî ïðè÷àñòåí è ê ýòþäíîìó òâîð÷åñòâó, íî… ñ÷èòàåò, ÷òî æàíð ýòþäîâ çíàåò ÒÎËÜÊÎ îí!... Óâû, ýòî íå òàê.
Äàëåå ïîñëåäîâàëî ïðàêòè÷åñêè åäèíîëè÷íîå ðåøåíèå Busa ïî PWCE.
Ñóäüè ïîäàëè ïðîòåñò.
Ïðîòåñò ïî òàêîé àâòîðèòàðíîé ðàáîòå ïîäàë è À. Êà÷þøêà.
Çíàÿ, ÷òî ïèñàòü ëè÷íî Bus áåñïîëåçíî (ìîæíî óòîíóòü â áþðîêðàòèè!) À. Êà÷þøêà íàïèñàë ïðîòåñò â FMJD, è âñåì ñîñòàâèòåëÿì, êîòîðûå ìîãóò áûòü çàèíòåðåñîâàíû â ýòîì. (Íó, â êîíöå êîíöîâ, íå ïèøåò çàÿö ïðîòåñò íà ïîâåäåíèå âîëêà, âîëêó!... Ïèøåò ÌÅÄÂÅÄÞ!)
È âîò ìû æäåì…
À ÷òî æå ìîæåò ñëó÷èòüñÿ?...
 DC FMJD ñåé÷àñ Ïòèöèí, Õèëüäåðèíã è Bus…
----
Îïÿòü Bus…
----
ßñíî, ÷òî Bus ÍÅ ÈÌÅÅÒ ÏÐÀÂÀ ãîëîñà ïî âîïðîñàì êàñàþùèìñÿ åãî ñàìîãî! Îí çàèíòåðåñîâàííîå ëèöî! Õèëüäåðèíã? Ýòî íå ñåêðåò: ó Õèëüäåðèíãà ñ Busom îáùèå äåëà è äðóæáà!... Êîíå÷íî æå Õèëüäåðèíã áðîñèòñÿ âñåìè äîçâîëåííûìè è íåäîçâîëåííûìè ñïîñîáàìè çàùèùàòü ÄÐÓÃÀ îò ýòèõ äèêàðåé ñ Âîñòîêà… È ìîæåò ñëó÷èòüñÿ, ÷òî îí íà÷íåò èãðó íå ïðàâèëàì. Íàïðèìåð ïîñòàâèò âîïðîñ: èëè/èëè! Èëè, äîïóñòèì, èç CPI óõîäèò À. Êà÷þøêà (à ïî÷åìó áû è íåò? Bus äàâíî óãðîæàåò Êà÷þøêå ñàíêöèÿìè!), èëè (÷òî áû òàêîå ñòðàøíîå ïðèäóìàòü?), íàïðèìåð, CPI èñêëþ÷àò èç FMJD! À ÷òî? Ýòî óãðîçà!
 äàííîé ñèòóàöèè î÷åíü âàæíà ðåàêöèÿ Ïòèöèíà, Ìàòóñà, Çóáîâà, âïðî÷åì, êàê è âñåãî ñîîáùåñòâà øàøå÷íûõ êîìïîçèòîðîâ, íî â ïåðâóþ î÷åðåäü ÈÕ!
Ìîå ëè÷íîå ìíåíèå?
CPI ñ Busom ìíå íå íóæíà…
Óæå ñåé÷àñ ÿ ÷óâñòâóþ, ÷òî ðàáîòàòü ñ íèì áóäåò ÏÐÎÑÒÎ ÍÅÂÎÇÌÎÆÍÎ!
CPI áåç FMJD?
Õì… À ìîæåò áûòü ýòî âûõîä?!
Ñåé÷àñ CPI (ñ Busom) òîðìîçèò òàêèå âîïðîñû êàê: 1) îðãàíèçàöèÿ CPI-64, 2) ðàñøèðåíèå CPI çà ñ÷åò Áåëàðóñè è Óêðàèíû, 3) ðàáîòà íàä Ïðàâèëàìè çàäà÷ è Ïðàâèëàìè äëÿ CPI-64. CPI äàæå íå âûïîëíÿåò ïðèíÿòûõ â Âàðøàâå ðåøåíèé…
----
È çäåñü òîðìîçèò Bus…
----
Ãîñïîäà, íî åñëè íà äîðîãå ëåæèò ÊÀÌÅÍÜ, åãî íàäî óáðàòü, à íå ÷åðòûõàòüñÿ êàæäóþ ìèíóòó!
Ìîæåò áûòü è äðóãîé âûõîä: ñäåëàòü îáúåçä! Íî ýòî, ñêîðåå âñåãî, èìåííî è áóäåò âûõîä CPI èç FMJD. Íåóæåëè FMJD ïàíàöåÿ? Íåóæåëè ìû íå ìîæåì ñîçäàòü Àññîöèàöèþ Øàøå÷íûõ Êîìïîçèòîðîâ, êîòîðàÿ ìîãëà áû áûòü ÇÀÐÅÃÈÑÒÐÈÐÎÂÀÍÀ þðèäè÷åñêè, è ïðîâîäèëà áû ×åìïèîíàòû Ìèðà âíå FMJD???
Ó áîêñåðîâ, äà è ó øàõìàòèñòîâ íå îäíî îáúåäèíåíèå ñ ïðàâîì ïðîâåäåíèÿ ×åìïèîíàòîâ Ìèðà ïî âåðñèè ***!
Ñåé÷àñ âèäèìî, íàäî ñìåíèòü âîïðîñ: «Êòî âèíîâàò?», íà âîïðîñ «×òî äåëàòü?»…
È ïîñòåïåííî íà÷àòü ÄÅËÀÒÜ Àññîöèàöèþ ÑÂÎÁÎÄÍÓÞ îò áþðîêðàòèçìà è äèêòàòà FMJD!
